Big IPOs Are Enticing, but Are They Good Investments?

Demand is strong heading into the first day of trading for Anthropic’s IPO on Thursday. But historically, buzzy debuts have been painful for buyers.

Collage illustration featuring 'IPO' at the center, surrounded by upward and downward-pointing triangles, with images of a building and coins.
Securities in This Article
Microsoft Corp
(MSFT)
Alphabet Inc Class A
(GOOGL)
Space Exploration Technologies Corp Class A
(SPCX)
Alphabet Inc Class C
(GOOG)
NVIDIA Corp
(NVDA)

Key Takeaways

  • Anthropic’s IPO appears to have drawn strong demand, but uncertainty about the AI trade and a hangover from the deal’s hype could cause headaches for investors who buy on the first day of trading.
  • While lucrative for companies and early investors, this year’s high-profile IPOs have mostly disappointed new shareholders.
  • Historically, buzzy new stocks have performed poorly in the year after their listings.

Big investors have been jostling for pieces of Anthropic’s IPO ahead of its first day of trading Thursday. But history suggests that buyers who aren’t at the front of the line fare poorly when newly minted stocks start trading.

The company on Wednesday reportedly priced shares at $83, a premium to the $70-$78 target range set last week. That higher price for Anthropic stocks comes as investors placed orders for more than six times the number of shares being sold, according to Bloomberg.

That strong demand underscores how eager investors are to own one of the biggest players in the AI boom, the first AI lab to go public. With interest that high, analysts say there’s a good chance that Anthropic stock—which will trade under the symbol ANT—will see a significant first-day pop above its offering price.

But investors who buy the stock after it starts trading—potentially well above what IPO buyers paid—face headwinds to earning profits. IPOs are always a gamble for retail investors, who risk paying a premium on Day One, when hype is strongest. Anthropic’s debut comes with its own risks, given the tremendous uncertainty about the outlook for AI business models.

A Big Year for IPO Sellers, but a Tough One for Buyers

Mega-listings like SpaceX SPCX and Anthropic are set to make 2026 a stellar year for IPOs. Through the end of the third quarter, 112 public listings raised $147.5 billion, more than three times what 202 IPOs raised in all of 2025, according to Renaissance.

However, huge listings have not translated into huge gains for new investors. On Tuesday, US-listed shares of memory chip giant SK Hynix SKHY closed about 18% below their July offering price. Shares of AI chipmaker Cerebras CBRS were nearly 45% off their IPO price and 70% below the price at which they actually began trading in May.

Even exceptions haven’t put in inspiring performances. SpaceX began trading at $150 a share, an 11% premium to its offering price, in June. In the 110 trading days since SpaceX’s record-breaking IPO, shares have closed below $150 on 74 occasions. SpaceX has spent more than 50% of its time as a public company, or 60 days, trading below its opening price.

The sheer amount of new stock available to public investors is likely hindering performance, according to Ben Inker, co-head of asset allocation at GMO. Historically, “when you got a lot of supply in the form of IPOs, that tended to harm the market,” he explains.

And IPOs aren’t the only source of new shares hitting the market. “Assuming the AI buildout is anything like as big as is forecast, the hyperscalers are going to have to do a significant amount of equity raising,” says Inker, referring to the tech companies like Microsoft MSFT and Amazon AMZN investing hundreds of billions annually in AI infrastructure. Alphabet GOOG/GOOGL and Meta Platforms META plan to raise as much as $40 billion and $95 billion through public offerings, respectively. (Alphabet aims to sell an additional $40 billion of equity privately.)

The Risks of Buying the Buzz

Companies and bankers usually aim for an IPO price that leaves room for the stock to pop on Day One. But a good first day of trading doesn’t guarantee smooth sailing in the following months. Listing in an exuberant market can be a detriment to near-term stock performance. That may have been the case for SK Hynix and Cerebras, both of which listed amid a blistering chip stock rally that has since unwound.

Companies going public have a lot to consider when pricing shares. They want to maximize proceeds by setting a high price, but it can’t be so high that they lose potential investors. There’s also an incentive to set a price that offers investors upside. “To the extent that they’d like to raise more capital in the future, it’s a lot easier if public investors can point to a gain instead of a loss,” says Matthew Kennedy, senior IPO market strategist at Renaissance.

Unfortunately for buyers of buzzy stocks, hype around an IPO can become a headwind once the market takes over. Of the 20 largest IPOs between 2010 and 2025, only four stocks were trading above their Day One closing prices a year later. On the flip side, six were down more than 50% after one year, and as a group, these 20 stocks posted a median 1-year return of -31%.

Sometimes a company makes a debut so explosive that new investors have little chance of upside. Few examples bear this out as clearly as Airbnb ABNB, which set an IPO price of $68 a share, but began trading at $146 in December 2020. The stock has spent about two-thirds of the days since trading below that price.

The story has been very different for the institutional investors who snagged Airbnb at its IPO price. The stock has never traded below $68. If an unlucky IPO buyer sold their stake at the worst possible moment—Dec. 28, 2022, when shares hit an all-time low of $81.91—they still banked a 20% return.

Anthropic Enters an Uneasy Market

Retail investors interested in Anthropic have more risks to consider. The Morningstar US Artificial Intelligence Index has declined more than 21% since early October. Stocks have been pressured by the threat of data center construction slowdowns in key states like Texas and Ohio following this year’s midterm elections. Even before the midterms, investors were worried about the sustainability of the data center boom and its long-term impact on the companies driving it. Wall Street’s jitters were amplified last week by the removal of Nvidia NVDA CEO Jensen Huang, one of AI’s most influential cheerleaders.

Those headwinds have already set Anthropic’s IPO back some. Its $83 IPO price values the company at about $1.5 trillion. That’s a handsome sum, but “the valuation talk was $2 trillion two months ago,” says Kennedy. He calls investors “more valuation-conscious” than in June, when Anthropic first filed IPO paperwork with federal regulators.

To be sure, plenty of strategists expect Anthropic’s listing to go well. “The fact that it even was able to launch at all after last week is somewhat remarkable,” says Kennedy of the roadshow that began days after tech stocks suffered their worst selloff in years. Considering the IPO is significantly oversubscribed, “I’m expecting a positive debut,” he says.

Some strategists say it would take a highly unusual shock for the IPO to fizzle. “If this IPO were a disaster and the price went down a lot immediately, that would have a very negative impact on the market,” says Inker, “but I assume if that were to happen, it would be because there was some disappointing or disturbing fundamental news that went out about Anthropic.”

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

Sponsor Center