What I Learned From My Lowest Returning Investments

Low returns may signal opportunity.

Collage illustration of pie chart featuring an investor holding binoculars, a stack of coins, and a whisker chart.
Securities in This Article
Fidelity Investment Grade Bond Fund
(FBNDX)
JPMorgan Core Plus Bond ETF
(JCPB)
Dodge & Cox Income Fund Class I
(DODIX)
PIMCO 1-5 Year U.S. TIPS Index Exchange-Traded Fund
(STPZ)
Fidelity Total Bond Fund
(FTBFX)

I was looking at my portfolio and noticed that my two worst performers suggested some intriguing places for contrarians to invest.

For the trailing five years, Pimco Total Return PTTRX has the worst returns, though it is ahead of its average peer. The reason: Inflation has spiked the bond market. Pimco Total Return is now down 0.2% annualized as 10- and 30-year Treasury yields are at their highest point since 2002.

That smarts. It shows how quickly a few years’ worth of gains can disappear when the bond market gets turned on its head. We’re big fans of the fund, which has a Morningstar Rating of Gold, because of its savvy managers and the massive resources of quantitative and fundamental analysts that Pimco can bring to bear for its flagship fund. I own this one in my 401(k).

But the good news is that yields are a good deal higher. If inflation and interest rates were to decline from here, those yields would look pretty good. If you want bonds without a ton of credit risk, you could go with Fidelity Total Bond FTBFX or Fidelity Investment Grade Bond FBNDX, which are rated Gold along with their exchange-traded fund versions. Core-plus funds have a bit more credit risk, so Gold-rated funds like Dodge & Cox Income DODIX and JPMorgan Core Plus Bond ETF JCPB are worth considering. They are, for my money, relatively restrained in their risk-taking compared with peers.

For the past three years, Vanguard Short-Term Inflation Protected Securities VTAPX/VTIP has been my worst performer, with a modest return of a cumulative 5.1% over that time. That’s actually good for its category and ranks in the top quartile. But once again, we’re led to a timely defensive play. As I write this, oil prices have popped to $105 per barrel on renewed fighting with Iran. If you have a big part of your portfolio in bonds, that’s a scary proposition. Inflation is poison for bonds as it undermines the fixed income you get from them.

Enter Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities funds like the Vanguard fund, and you have a useful inflation hedge. Short-term TIPS are a better bet than long-term ones because long-term TIPS funds have a lot of interest rate risk. So, if interest rates rise to tamp down inflation, you are losing money because of duration while making it from inflation.

The Gold-rated Vanguard fund is a great option among the short-term TIPS group. Gold-rated Pimco 1-5 Year U.S. TIPS Index ETF STPZ is another attractive option. It has a little more duration and a slightly higher expense ratio. The Vanguard fund is slightly ahead on a three- and five-year return basis.

One caveat with TIPS funds is that you should be sure to hold them in a tax-sheltered account. (Mine is in my 401(k).) TIPS adjust their prices to reflect changes in the inflation rate. However, they are taxed on upward adjustments in the year they are made rather than when they are sold. This is one tax situation that the ETF wrapper doesn’t help. On an aftertax return basis, the Vanguard fund’s three- and five-year returns fall to 1.3% annualized and 1.6% annualized, so keep them in your IRA or 401(k).

This article first appeared in the October 2026 issue of Morningstar FundInvestor. Download a complimentary copy of FundInvestor by visiting this website.

The author or authors own shares in one or more securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

Sponsor Center