Target Earnings: Category Resets Drive Traffic, but Apparel and Home Temper Mix
We plan to raise our fair value estimate of Target stock.

Key Morningstar Metrics for Target
- Fair Value Estimate: $131.00
- Morningstar Rating: ★★
- Morningstar Economic Moat Rating: None
- Morningstar Uncertainty Rating: High
What We Thought of Target’s Earnings
Target’s TGT third-quarter results included a 5.6% comparable sales increase and an adjusted EPS of $2.15, up 21.0%. Core gross margin expanded 120 basis points to 29.4% after lapping higher markdowns alongside greater supply chain efficiency, partly offset by higher fuel costs and category mix pressure.
Why it matters: Target’s merchandising overhaul is restoring traffic and relevance. However, we question the long-term durability of growth as food, beauty, and trend-driven hardlines (Fun 101) outpace higher-margin apparel and home, where a recovery remains incomplete.
- Traffic rose 5%, as food and beverage sales grew nearly 7%, beauty over 9%, and hardlines 27%. However, trading cards drove 40% of year-to-date hardlines growth, raising the bar for continued gains as Target laps this outsize demand in the future.
- Home returned to slight growth (2.5%) following assortment resets, but women’s fashion continues to weigh on apparel (down 3.8%). We believe this highlights Target’s midmarket positioning, leaving it vulnerable to lower-priced competitors or stronger offerings.
The bottom line: We plan to raise our fair value estimate of $131 for no-moat Target by a low-single-digit percentage, reflecting modestly lifted near-term sales assumptions after stronger-than-expected third-quarter sales. Shares trade roughly 20% above our valuation, following a 4% rise on Nov. 18.
- We estimate the market implies an average operating margin of 6.6% over the next decade, which we see as unlikely (versus our 5.7% forecast), as we expect an ongoing sales mix shift toward lower-margin categories that leaves the firm heavily execution-dependent and caps margin gains.
Coming up: For the holidays, Target is introducing 8,000 new gifts, 50% being exclusive and most priced at $20 or less. While low entry price points should resonate with stretched consumers, we think these temporary promotional catalysts are insufficient to improve its competitive positioning.
Editor’s Note: This analysis was originally published as a stock note by Morningstar Equity Research.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.
