When corporate executives say they value diversity, do they mean it? Can they point to significant actions they are taking to improve representation within their workforce? Are their efforts having measurable success?
And what happens then? Even if a company has progressive recruiting practices, do people of color stand the same chance of being promoted to management ranks as white employees? How about at executive levels? And is there a diverse board of directors to push the company toward greater equity? Moreover, have company leaders taken steps to make their workplace more inclusive? Does the corporate culture condemn discrimination and celebrate difference? Is the company mindful of its social impact?
These questions demand answers, especially now. The coronavirus pandemic has disproportionately affected African Americans. The killing of George Floyd by Minneapolis police has shone a harsh light on deeply entrenched practices and inequities that continue to marginalize and oppress people of color. Consider that the median net worth of a white household in the United States is 10 times greater than that of a black household, a disparity that has grown over the past half-century. As Kareem Abdul-Jabar wrote in a recent op-ed in the Los Angeles Times:
"Racism in America is like dust in the air. It seems invisible--even if you’re choking on it--until you let the sun in. Then you see it’s everywhere. As long as we keep shining that light, we have a chance of cleaning it wherever it lands. But we have to stay vigilant, because it’s always still in the air."
To this end, corporate America must be held accountable. Corporations have a critical role to play in changing society for the better. And not only is diversity and inclusion the right thing to do from a social perspective, it also leads to better business outcomes: Research from McKinsey, Credit Suisse, and others have shown that more diverse companies achieve superior financial results. The reason is pretty unequivocal: Different perspectives foster innovation and improve decision-making.
You Can't Change What You Can't Measure In 2018, Morningstar launched a Minority Empowerment Index to highlight companies that stand out for their commitment to diversity and inclusion. The index's selection criteria incorporates factors used by the NAACP to measure corporations' commitment to equality in areas like board diversity, discrimination policies, and community development programs. It relies upon the company-level analysis of Sustainalytics, which specializes in environmental, social, and governance research. (Sustainalytics has agreed to be acquired by Morningstar.)
Companies are assigned a Minority Empowerment Score based on their commitment to racial and ethnic diversity within their workforce, boards, supply chains, and society at large. Policies and programs are considered, but--importantly--emphasis is also placed on measurable behavior. Therefore, a company isn’t eligible for the index if Sustainalytics judges it to have a poor track record on matters related to diversity and inclusion; this is determined based on a careful examination of incidents and controversies.
Here are a few of the main components of the Minority Empowerment Score:
Board diversity: This indicator assesses the level of gender and/or national diversity on the board. Sustainalytics looks at the proportion of women on the board and the quality of the board's diversity policy (for example, does the company include targets and commitments to increase board diversity?)
Discrimination policy: This indicator assesses the quality of a company's policies to eliminate discrimination and ensure equal opportunity.
Diversity programs: This indicator assesses the strength of a company’s initiatives to increase the diversity of its workforce. Corporate culture is examined, paying specific attention to:
- Employee affinity groups, diversity councils, or networking groups
- Mentorship programs
- Initiatives supporting a diverse workforce
- Diversity monitoring or audits
- Managerial or board-level responsibility for diversity initiatives
- Targeted recruitment
- Training and guidance regarding diversity
- Diversity initiatives that go beyond legal compliance
Scope of social supplier standards: This indicator provides a general assessment of whether a company has supply chain/contractor policies regarding items such as nondiscrimination.
15 Companies That Are Committed to Change These companies achieve high Minority Empowerment Scores because they have demonstrated a strong commitment to diversity and inclusion across several indicators. Those marked with an "X" are areas where the company has demonstrated particular strength.
Morningstar assigns Economic Moat Ratings of “wide,” “narrow,” or “none” as a way to evaluate the size and strength of a company’s competitive advantage. Wide- or narrow-moat companies have sustainable advantages that should allow them to fend off their competitors and generate positive economic profits. The Morningstar Minority Empowerment Index currently has more exposure to wide-moat companies and less exposure to no-moat companies than the broad market.
Click on the company names below to read more about each company's ongoing efforts to achieve a more diverse and inclusive workforce.
Microsoft MSFT Citigroup C Coca-Cola KO Intel INTC NortonLifeLock NLOK Morgan Stanley MS General Electric GE S&P Global SPGI Nielsen Holdings NLSN Biogen BIIB International Paper IP Dell Technologies DELL Hewlett Packard Enterprise HPE Bank of America BAC HP HPQ
Disclosure: Morningstar, Inc. licenses indexes to financial institutions as the tracking indexes for investable products, such as exchange-traded funds, sponsored by the financial institution. The license fee for such use is paid by the sponsoring financial institution based mainly on the total assets of the investable product. Please click here for a list of investable products that track or have tracked a Morningstar index. Neither Morningstar, Inc. nor its investment management division markets, sells, or makes any representations regarding the advisability of investing in any investable product that tracks a Morningstar index.