How Today’s Markets Stack Up Against the Past 20 Years
Plus, signals from key indicators, including oil, gold, and the US dollar.
Ivanna Hampton: Welcome to Investing Insights. I’m your host, Ivanna Hampton. The markets are giving investors plenty of trends to watch in 2026, and the macro environment’s effect on gold, interest rates, and the US housing market is fueling uncertainty. How do today’s trends compare to historical ones? And how should you think about them to be a savvier investor? Joining me is Morningstar portfolio strategist and co-host of The Long View podcast Amy Arnott.
It’s good to see you, Amy.
Amy Arnott: Good to see you, too.
Hampton: Let’s talk about market uncertainty this year. What moments do you think are significant and why?
Arnott: We’ve had a lot of things going on. Obviously, there’s the war in Iran. We’ve had inflation running hotter than expected. We’ve had one interest rate hike in September, possibly another one before the end of the year. A lot of enthusiasm, but also fear around AI. So a lot of things going on in different areas of the market, but of all those things, the one I would point to as being most significant is inflation. And that’s something that worries me the most as an investor, because even if we do see inflation eventually moderating, you typically don’t see prices going down. That means it’s kind of a permanent increase in your cost of living, which can be very difficult, especially for people who are already retired and not generating a regular income.
Hampton: That is important to highlight. I think a lot of people think once you clamp down on inflation, eggs will return to the price that you remember four or five years ago.
Arnott: Right. And maybe certain things will, but you still see that overall cost increase in the price of living.
Hampton: All right. There’s a quarterly research report from Morningstar that provides a big-picture outlook at current market trends while comparing them to the last two decades. You really like one chart called the Market Thermometer. Talk about why it provides a wealth of information to investors.
Arnott: The Market Thermometer shows seven key market indicators and their current level relative to their high and low over the past 20 years. I like it partly because it gives such a long-term perspective. And I also like it because we scale the values so that you can compare different things relative to each other. So, you can get a really insightful view of the overall market at a glance, which is nice.
Hampton: We’re going to focus on the seven key indicators from that chart. Let’s start with gold. Its price is still relatively high but has declined nearly 30% from its peak in January. What’s dulling the appeal of this traditionally safe-haven investment?
Arnott: I think one factor is rising interest rates. And if you have higher yields available on bonds and cash, there’s less of a reason for investors to take shelter in gold, which doesn’t generate any yield or cash flows on a regular basis. And I would argue that even though gold is traditionally viewed as a safe haven, as you said, I think it’s becoming more of a speculative asset where you had a lot of people buying while it was on the way up, and then when the price started going down, you had more selling pressure. I think that is also part of the reason why it’s fallen so much so far this year.
Hampton: That’s interesting to note, to sort of think of maybe it’s transitioning.
Arnott: Right.
Hampton: Next up is higher interest rates. They’re sitting toward the high end of their range over the past 20 years, but that’s a good thing for investors saving up for short-term goals, right?
Arnott: Right. So if you go back to 2011, we had the zero interest rate policy at the Federal Reserve. And as the name implies, interest rates were close to zero. So, savers were really getting close to nothing on short-term deposits and even longer-term bond funds. Now we’re in a much better situation where the three-month Treasury bill is yielding about 4%. You’re getting a pretty decent yield and actually staying a little bit ahead of inflation, which is a good thing.
Hampton: And a quick follow-up: What about bond investors?
Arnott: Rising interest rates are obviously bad for longer-term bond investors. We’ve seen the yield on the 10-year Treasury bond increase by about a full percentage point so far this year, which has been bad for long-duration assets. So if you look at a long-term Treasury fund like TLT [iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF], for example, that fund is down 7% or 8% so far this year.
Hampton: Let’s talk about the US stock market. Strong earnings growth is one of the reasons why US stock prices are elevated. What’s at stake if corporate earnings miss expectations?
Arnott: One thing I would point out is if you look at the overall PE for the Morningstar US Market Index, it’s actually down a bit from peak levels. And a lot of that is because even though stock prices have continued climbing, we’ve also seen strong earnings growth. So, that denominator in the PE ratio, if you have a bigger E, the overall number is going down. That said, market valuations are still relatively high, which means if we do see any weakness in corporate earnings, there’s more room for stocks to fall.
Hampton: And a quick follow-up: How are international stocks faring against US stocks in 2026?
Arnott: Earlier this year, international stocks pulled ahead. In the past two or three months, they’ve been a bit behind, partly because of inflation concerns in Europe, also some weakness in AI and tech-related stocks in emerging markets. But overall for the full year-to-date period, US and non-US stocks are about the same in terms of total returns. And the fact that US stocks and international stocks have had different performance patterns so far this year, I think really underscores the value of diversification and making sure you have some exposure to both of those areas.
Hampton: And that’s the word we always expect from you: diversification.
Arnott: Exactly.
Hampton: Oil prices are experiencing highs and lows this year. How should investors think about this commodity?
Arnott: We’ve seen lots of volatility in oil prices so far this year. The Brent crude oil price is up about 70% so far this year. And so I think one thing you can take away from that is it’s an extremely volatile asset, and a lot of the recent price gains are being driven by the war in Iran and supply constraints from the blockade in the Strait of Hormuz. I think that if you look at oil and energy more broadly, it’s still a pretty good hedge against inflation risk. But I think for the average investor, you probably want to be in a more diversified commodities fund and as a relatively small percentage of your portfolio as a hedge against inflation.
Hampton: Another indicator is bitcoin. How do the digital currency’s prices compare to their historical average, and why is it more attractive now than a year ago?
Arnott: This is another asset that has had extreme volatility, probably even more so than oil prices. If you go back to when bitcoin first started trading, it was just a few cents per coin, all the way up to a peak of about $125,000 per coin back in October 2025. We’re now about half of that level, so it does look more attractive than it did a year ago. But again, with no underlying cash flows, it’s very difficult to pin down what the price of bitcoin should be. So, it’s an asset class that I think investors should treat with extreme caution. And I think the average investor probably doesn’t need exposure to bitcoin. If you do want to have some exposure, I would keep it to a very small percentage of your portfolio, maybe 2% or 3% of assets at the most.
Hampton: What kind of year is the US dollar having as central banks stock their reserves with other currencies?
Arnott: We saw some pretty significant pressure on the US dollar last year when central banks around the world were de-dollarizing their assets. So far this year, the dollar is up about 2%, but I think overall it’s still on the high end of its range over the past 20 years. So, even though we’ve seen more strength in the dollar so far this year, I think it’s always a good idea for investors to have some exposure to nondollar assets, so something like an international-stock fund that doesn’t hedge its currency exposure.
Hampton: The seventh and final indicator is real US home prices. They’re very high, close to their all-time high in 2024. That is a problem for first-time homebuyers. Can you talk about how current homeowners can benefit from their equity?
Arnott: Right. I think especially if you’re an older person who is already retired and you were able to buy a home maybe 20 or 30 years ago, you probably are sitting on a decent amount of home equity, which can be a really valuable asset in retirement. If you’re willing to downsize to move to a smaller home, you could use the proceeds from a home sale to help cover your cost of living each month so that you have more portfolio assets to draw from. A lot of people also like to use proceeds from a home sale to buy into a continuing care retirement community. And it can also be a nice buffer or insurance type of asset if you do end up needing long-term care. That home equity is something you could potentially use if you are able to sell your home and use the proceeds to cover part of or all of the cost for long-term care.
Hampton: What’s the takeaway for investors as they’re tracking the trends we just discussed?
Arnott: If you look at all of these indicators, they’re all above average, which could be cause for some concern. We don’t see any blaring alarm bells in terms of overall market valuations like we might’ve seen back in 1999. But the fact that so many of these market indicators are on the high end of their long-term range, I think is reason to be cautious. And again, make sure your portfolio is diversified; make sure that the type of assets you have are a good fit for your time horizon and your goals.
Hampton: Wonderful takeaways, Amy. Thank you for coming to the table, and Happy Thanksgiving.
Arnott: Happy Thanksgiving to you, too.
Hampton: I appreciate you for checking out Investing Insights this week, and here’s my nudge to add The Long View to your queue. The latest episode focuses on why the years before retirement can be so risky. Co-hosts Amy Arnott and Ben Johnson talked with David Blanchett. He’s the head of retirement research for Prudential Financial. Click the link in the show notes to listen to their conversation. Thanks to senior video producer Jake VanKersen and associate multimedia editor Jess Bebel. I’m Ivanna Hampton, editorial multimedia manager at Morningstar. Take care.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

