Out of Style, Out of Patience: Why MFS Investors Are Leaving
A deeper dive into MFS’ recent struggles and whether the firm can bounce back.

Active equity managers have had a rough stretch, and few have been hit harder than MFS. The Boston-based firm, known for its deep analyst bench, experienced portfolio managers, and long-term approach, has struggled. Weak stock-picking within technology combined with style headwinds weighed heavily on many portfolios’ performance in recent years. Now, investors are growing impatient: MFS’ US and international equity funds shed nearly $50 billion in the first 10 months of 2026, which was roughly 17% of the cohort’s assets at the beginning of the year.
A Shared Philosophy
Most MFS managers share a similar approach. They generally seek companies with durable competitive advantages trading at reasonable prices. They hold them for the long term, often five years or more. The approach naturally tilts their portfolios toward quality and low-volatility stocks. But that approach, while sound, has been out of favor over much of the past six years. Following the early-2020 pandemic selloff through 2021, cyclical stocks rallied hard and MFS funds lagged. The funds gained back some lost ground when cyclical and technology stocks pulled back in 2022, but that selloff was brief and the same stylistic headwinds persisted into 2024.
Then came artificial intelligence. Up until that point, many of the firm’s portfolios were either underweight in the technology sector or were lighter in many of the fastest-growing areas of the sector owing to the managers’ valuation sensitivity. So, when AI-related stocks gained momentum in 2025, many of the firm’s portfolios were poorly positioned to take advantage of the rally. And because of their long-term approach, many of the managers were slow to react to the shift and performance suffered.
MFS Equity Funds' Rolling 3-Year Excess Returns Versus Category Average
Struggling Together
Many firms have a shared investment philosophy or a general specialty, but few are as focused as MFS. Among large asset managers, MFS’ US equity funds’ have been one of the most highly correlated. The firm has had success across its strategies, until the recent tech-led rally when quality fell out of favor. Consequently, the firm’s strategies have hit a rough patch at the same time.
Of the firm’s 33 US and international equity funds with at least a three-year track record through October 2026, only 10 landed in the top half of their Morningstar Category over the trailing three-year period. The recent results have weighed on long-term results, and the five- and 10-year results aren’t much better.
While firmwide performance ebbs and flows, MFS’ underperformance has been more widespread than peers’. Its success ratio—or the percentage of a company’s US open-end mutual funds that rank in the top half of their respective Morningstar Categories—was just 35% over the three-year period, lowest among a cohort of similar large asset managers.
Asset Manager 3-Year Success Ratios
Technology Troubles
It’s hard to blame MFS entirely for missing some AI winners. Many were less established companies with weak fundamentals that didn’t meet MFS’ quality test. But technology has long been a soft spot.
Take MFS Massachusetts Investors Trust MITTX for instance. There, the managers own many of the mega-cap tech stocks (Nvidia NVDA, Apple AAPL, Microsoft MSFT, Alphabet GOOGL, and Amazon.com AMZN) at a weighting similar to the fund’s Russell 1000 Index prospectus benchmark. But the managers’ aversion to cyclical companies has often steered them away from the growthiest segments of the market, including semiconductors. Despite decent stock-picking in other sectors of the market, not buying Broadcom AVGO and Advanced Micro Devices AMD until early-mid 2026 were two errors of omission that partially offset strong picks elsewhere.
MFS Massachusetts Investors Trust—Information Technology Cumulative Growth
Many of the firm’s large-cap growth managers have been underweight in technology mega-caps, which explains part of their shortfall, and its small- and mid-cap strategies have also lagged in the sector, albeit by less.
Losing Patience
Investors’ patience with the underperformance has started to wane. According to Morningstar’s data, investors pulled nearly $50 billion from the firm’s US and international equity funds in the year to date through October 2026. Only Capital Group and T. Rowe Price had more outflows over the period.
Asset Managers With Largest Outflows YTD 2026
To make matters worse, MFS anticipates several of its funds will issue large capital gains distributions. The outflows likely caused managers to sell shares of longtime winners, so investors who own a few of MFS’ funds in taxable accounts should expect a large tax bill. MFS Global Equity MWEFX and MFS Growth MFEGX are projected to have two of the family’s largest tax bills this year. As of September 2026, MFS projects that MFS Global Equity will pay a distribution of more than 30% of the fund’s net asset value while MFS Massachusetts Investors Growth Stock MIGFX projects to pay out nearly 27% of its net asset value.
What’s Next?
It has undoubtedly been a tough stretch for MFS and its investors. Its focus on high-quality, durable companies and long-term approach has worked against it for several years, mostly recently in the AI-driven rally. But rather than compromise on their principles, MFS managers have stuck with their time-tested approach and continue to trust the philosophy that has led the firm to more than 100 years of success.
There are early signs that their discipline may be paying off. When quality stocks came back into favor from July through October 2026, many MFS funds made up ground. Four months is a short window, but it’s encouraging that the funds are still performing well when you’d expect. MFS has a lot of ground to make up, but when durable, quality stocks come back into favor, don’t be surprised if MFS is leading the pack.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.
