This 4-Star Stock Is Up 25% in a Month. Is It Still a Buy?
The market’s pessimism may have created an opportunity for investors.

Investors have been hard on Pentair , but the water technology company is starting to bounce back. The stock still trades 27% below Morningstar’s $91 fair value estimate and was one of Morningstar Chief US Market Strategist Dave Sekera‘s picks on a recent episode of The Morning Filter podcast, 5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings.
Pentair is a pure-play water company manufacturing a wide range of sustainable water products, including energy-efficient swimming pool pumps, filtration solutions, and commercial and industrial pumps. Its business is organized into three segments: pool, water solutions, and flow. The company benefits from a large installed base of equipment; over 75% of its products are replacement parts.
Key Morningstar Metrics for Pentair
- Fair Value Estimate: $91
- Star Rating: 4 Stars
- Economic Moat Rating: Narrow
- Uncertainty Rating: Medium
Economic Moat Rating
We believe that Pentair has a narrow economic moat attributable to customer switching costs and intangible assets. The company derives roughly two-thirds of its revenue from aftermarket service and replacement parts, which are tied to its large installed base. Because many of its products perform mission-critical functions, failures could lead to costly outages for customers. Thus, quality and reliability are paramount, and customers seldom pursue cost savings by switching to cheaper alternatives. We believe Pentair is well positioned to earn excess economic profits over the next decade.
Read more about Pentair’s moat rating.
Fair Value Estimate for Pentair Stock
Our fair value estimate is $91 per share. We assume average compound annual organic revenue growth of roughly 4% through 2030. In the long run, we forecast revenue growth in the low single digits in flow, midsingle digits in water solutions, and midsingle digits in pool. We project adjusted operating margin to expand from 25.2% in 2025 to roughly 27% in 2030, driven by business simplification, corporate rightsizing, mix shift, and a focus on more profitable product lines. We assume an 8.6% weighted average cost of capital and an 18% long-run effective tax rate in our model.
Read more about Pentair’s fair value estimate.
Risk and Uncertainty
Pentair’s risk is somewhat offset by its strong brand portfolio and large installed base. To mitigate the impact of tariffs, the company has implemented tariff-related price increases, prebought inventory, and capped orders to avoid disruptions in the supply chain. Nonetheless, cost inflation and tariff-related disruption could dent Pentair’s profitability. We think the largest environmental, social, and governance risks include potential product quality and safety issues and failure to comply with various environmental as well as health and safety laws.
Read more about Pentair’s risk and uncertainty.
Pentair Bulls Say
- Pentair is a pure-play water company poised to benefit from demand for sustainable and energy-efficient water solutions.
- The pool business continues to deliver solid revenue growth, consistent market share gains, and lucrative operating margins.
- Pentair’s transformation initiatives have driven strong margin expansion in recent years.
Pentair Bears Say
- Growth has been relatively sluggish and may remain elusive in the flow segment.
- Persistent strength in the US dollar could make Pentair more susceptible to offshore competition.
- Cost inflation could be a headwind in the short run.
5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings
This article was compiled by Jess Bebel and Sylvia Hauser. Data as of Nov. 17, 2026, close unless otherwise noted.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.
