New IRS Guidance Raises the Stakes for Section 351 ETF Exchange Strategies

Tax-efficient ETF conversions can still offer benefits, but advisors and investors must distinguish legitimate portfolio transitions from transactions likely to attract scrutiny.

Collage illustration of the word "Tax" with a calculator and geometric shapes in the background.

Recent IRS guidance (see here and here) raises important questions about how Section 351 exchanges are structured.

On Nov. 4, Matt Zenz, chief investment officer of Longview Research Partners, and Brent Sullivan, founder of Tax Alpha Insider, presented a webinar examining recent IRS and US Treasury guidance on Section 351 exchanges into exchange-traded funds. Their presentation included research conducted by Longview on more than 100 historical Section 351 ETF launches, highlighting significant differences in how these transactions have been structured and implemented.

The findings are important for both investors and financial advisors. While Section 351 exchanges can be a powerful tool for improving taxable portfolios, recent IRS guidance has raised legitimate concerns about certain implementations. The appropriate response is not to avoid these opportunities or wait indefinitely for additional guidance but for investors and advisors to instead take the time to better understand the risks and to ask more demanding questions of the ETF sponsors offering them.

Section 351 Exchanges: A Valuable Tool for Tax-Efficient Portfolio Management

One of the most persistent challenges in wealth management is the conflict between sound investment decisions and tax considerations.

Investors often hold portfolios that no longer reflect an appropriate investment strategy because selling appreciated securities would trigger substantial capital gains taxes. The result is tax-induced portfolio inertia: Investors continue holding securities they would otherwise sell because realizing the embedded gains would be costly.

Section 351 exchanges into ETFs offer a potentially powerful solution.

Under appropriate circumstances, investors can contribute appreciated securities to a newly formed ETF in exchange for ETF shares without immediately recognizing capital gains. The investor’s tax basis generally carries over, preserving the deferred gain, while the ETF provides professional management, diversification, and potentially lower ongoing costs.

Section 351 does not eliminate the investor’s tax liability. It generally defers recognition while allowing the investor to change the form in which an investment is held. For investors and for advisors managing taxable portfolios, that flexibility can be extremely valuable.

What the IRS Is Concerned About

On Sept. 28, 2026, the IRS and Treasury issued Notice 2026-62 and Revenue Ruling 2026-20, addressing certain transactions involving Section 351 and Section 852(b)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Section 351 generally permits the transfer of appreciated property to a corporation in exchange for its stock without immediate gain recognition, provided certain requirements are satisfied. For investment companies, additional restrictions apply under Section 351(e), including rules intended to prevent certain tax-free diversification transactions.

Section 852(b)(6), meanwhile, generally permits qualifying regulated investment companies to distribute appreciated securities in redemption of their shares without recognizing gains at the fund level. This provision is a major contributor to the tax efficiency of ETFs.

Both provisions serve legitimate purposes. The IRS’ concern arises when they are combined as part of a “prearranged series of transactions” intended to accomplish something neither provision was designed to permit.

Consider a hypothetical transaction.

An investor contributes appreciated securities to a newly launched ETF whose intended investment strategy differs materially from the contributed portfolio. Shortly after launch, the ETF issues shares to an authorized participant in exchange for securities consistent with its strategy, then redeems those shares by distributing securities originally contributed by the investor.

The result is that the investor has effectively exchanged one portfolio for a materially different portfolio without recognizing the embedded gains.

In Revenue Ruling 2026-20, the IRS concludes that the described transaction should be treated according to its economic substance rather than its individual legal steps. The investor is treated as having engaged in a taxable exchange with the authorized participant under Section 1001.

However, the IRS also makes an important distinction.

Notice 2026-62 expressly states that it does not address, and expresses no view regarding, Section 351 transactions used to seed newly established ETFs with securities consistent with the ETF’s investment thesis that are intended and expected to be retained absent a substantial change in circumstances.

That language is not a safe harbor. It does, however, signal a distinction between ordinary ETF seeding and the planned portfolio-substitution transactions that are attracting scrutiny.

For advisors, the question is whether the investment strategy, contributed assets, and anticipated portfolio management support the economic rationale for the transaction.

What Historical Section 351 Transactions Can Teach Us

Longview Research Partners examined more than 100 historical ETF launches involving Section 351 exchanges since 2021. For each fund, the research evaluated which assets were contributed, whether those assets aligned with the stated investment strategy, and how the portfolio was rebalanced following launch.

The findings revealed considerable variation in implementation, including in-kind redemptions under Section 852(b)(6) shortly after inception, sequential Section 351 contributions, and contributed assets that appeared inconsistent with the receiving fund’s investment mandate.

These observations do not establish that any particular transaction was improper. In-kind redemptions are a normal feature of ETF operations, and their timing alone does not establish an abusive transaction.

However, the research illustrates why the details matter.

One manager may accept securities because they are consistent with a long-term investment strategy and are expected to remain in the portfolio, subject to normal investment management decisions. Another may accept securities principally because the manager intends to replace them with a materially different portfolio through a planned series of in-kind redemptions.

The investors’ initial experience might appear similar, but their tax analysis could be substantially different.

This creates an important responsibility for investors and advisors: understanding not only the ETF being offered but also how the sponsor intends to implement the exchange.

5 Questions Investors and Advisors Should Ask

The recent IRS guidance reinforces the importance of due diligence. While no single factor determines the tax treatment of a transaction, investors and advisors should consider five questions when evaluating an opportunity.

1. What securities will the ETF accept through the Section 351 exchange?

One of the clearest distinctions in the IRS guidance concerns “whether contributed securities are consistent with the ETF’s investment strategy.”

An ETF designed to invest broadly across US equities might reasonably accept a diversified portfolio of US stocks. Accepting emerging-market securities into a US equity fund, however, raises questions about why those assets are being contributed and whether the manager genuinely intends to hold them.

Longview’s research identified instances in which ETFs accepted securities that appeared inconsistent with their stated investment mandates. While this does not necessarily establish improper conduct, it highlights an important area of due diligence and a potential concern regarding the exchange’s tax treatment.

Investors and advisors should understand which securities are eligible and whether the manager has an economic rationale for owning them beyond facilitating the exchange.

2. What is the manager’s process for rebalancing the portfolio following the exchange?

The IRS’ concerns focus in part on arrangements combining Section 351 contributions with planned in-kind redemptions under Section 852(b)(6) to accomplish tax-free portfolio substitution.

Longview’s research found that some ETFs conducted in-kind redemptions within just a few days of their initial Section 351 exchanges, replacing nearly all of their seeded assets with materially different securities and exposures. While timing alone does not establish improper conduct, it raises questions about whether those transactions reflected normal investment management or a prearranged plan.

Advisors should understand how the manager determines portfolio weights, what drives trading decisions, and whether significant changes to contributed holdings are anticipated after launch.

Importantly, no prescribed holding period automatically makes a transaction permissible. The economic rationale and overall arrangement matter more than an arbitrary number of days.

3. Has the sponsor executed Section 351 exchanges before?

Section 351 exchanges require coordination across investment management, fund operations, custodians, tax counsel, and participating investors.

Experience provides an opportunity to evaluate how a sponsor has managed these complexities in practice. Investors and advisors should ask about prior exchanges, what securities were accepted, how the portfolios were subsequently managed, and whether the sponsor encountered operational or tax-related challenges.

Prior experience does not guarantee favorable tax treatment, but it provides useful evidence of the sponsor’s capabilities. Advisors should also understand whether qualified tax counsel has reviewed the proposed transaction in light of the recent IRS guidance.

4. What is the risk that the ETF will fail to attract sufficient assets or eventually close?

An often-overlooked risk is the long-term viability of the resulting ETF.

Investors may successfully defer substantial capital gains through a Section 351 exchange, only to face an unexpected taxable event if the ETF subsequently liquidates. For example, if a fund offers indexlike exposure but with a higher fee than existing ETFs, the strategy may struggle to attract inflows after launch. As initial investors liquidate their positions, outflows could leave the fund with insufficient assets to remain viable for the sponsor. The fund could then be liquidated. Investors and advisors should evaluate the fund’s initial asset base, anticipated inflows, expense structure, distribution capabilities, and the sponsor’s commitment to maintaining the strategy.

For an investor intending to hold an ETF for decades, the fund’s longevity deserves consideration alongside the initial tax benefits.

5. Is this an investment I actually want to own for the long term?

The final question may be the most important.

Tax deferral is valuable, but it should not be the primary reason for selecting an investment strategy. Advisors should evaluate the ETF’s expected returns, diversification, risk exposures, fees, and investment philosophy independently of the Section 351 opportunity.

An exchange that avoids an immediate tax liability but leaves the investor in an expensive or inappropriate strategy may ultimately destroy more value than it creates.

The fundamental question is straightforward: If the ETF already existed and there were no Section 351 opportunity, would the investor still buy it, and would the advisor still recommend it to the client?

The Cost of Getting It Wrong

The consequences of an improperly structured exchange can be significant.

If an investor expects a tax-deferred contribution but the transaction is subsequently recharacterized as a taxable exchange, the investor could face an unexpected capital gains tax liability, potentially accompanied by interest and penalties. Revenue Ruling 2026-20 could be applied to conversions that occurred before its publication. Thus, investors who have already completed a conversion-type transaction may face this exposure now, not just prospectively.

That risk is particularly relevant for investors with substantial embedded gains, for whom tax deferral may represent a significant part of the transaction’s expected benefit.

At the same time, uncertainty should not be confused with prohibition. The IRS has identified a particular transaction structure that it concludes produces a taxable result. Nor has the IRS declared that Section 351 exchanges into ETFs are categorically impermissible.

Waiting for all uncertainty to disappear is not a practical investment strategy. The appropriate response is to understand the rules, evaluate the facts, seek qualified advice, and make informed decisions.

Upcoming Opportunities to Learn More

For investors and advisors interested in Section 351 exchanges, Longview Research Partners is planning two new US equity ETFs in the first quarter of 2027.

The funds target different segments of the US equity market and serve different roles within client portfolios. Longview is holding educational webinars covering their investment strategies and the mechanics and eligibility criteria for participating in a Section 351 exchange:

Note: I have no relationship to Longview Research Partners, and the five due diligence questions above apply to these funds as well.

The Bottom Line

Section 351 exchanges can help solve a long-standing problem in wealth management: Investors remaining in suboptimal portfolios because the tax cost of changing is too high.

The recent IRS guidance should not cause advisors to abandon this opportunity. It should reinforce the importance of distinguishing transactions grounded in a legitimate investment strategy from those designed primarily to manufacture a particular tax outcome.

The objective is not merely to defer capital gains. It is to use tax efficiency to help investors achieve a better long-term investment outcome.

That is an opportunity worth pursuing, provided investors and advisors do their homework.

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

Larry Swedroe is a freelance writer. The opinions expressed here are the author’s. Morningstar values diversity of thought and publishes a broad range of viewpoints.

Sponsor Center