America is definitely rich enough to fix Social Security and Medicare. Here's how.
By Brett Arends
This one, simple, low-pain tax solves all the problems
Pay 1% a year? Moi?
To hear many people tell it, America's looming fiscal crises can't be fixed without enormous pain or costs - if it at all.
The country's national debt just hit $40 trillion, equal to about 100% of annual gross domestic product. Social Security's trust fund is due to run out of money in 2032 (or 2034 at the latest), and without some radical fix, benefits would have to be slashed by about a fifth. Medicare's Part A (hospital insurance) trust fund is due to run out of money around the same time. The trust fund for Medicare Part B (medical insurance) doesn't even have any money; it is funded by general tax revenues.
Any look at the long-term numbers seems terrifying: Trillions of dollars in deficits and unfunded liabilities, stretching as far as the eye can see.
Some say we will need to slash retirement benefits for future retirees, and drop millions from Medicaid (the latter is actually happening; it was part of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, along with tax cuts). Others talk about hefty income-tax hikes - for example, by abolishing the cap on the incomes subject to Social Security payroll taxes, which would effectively add an extra 12.4% tax on all income over $192,300 (in 2027).
Others offer big "wealth" taxes applied to the rich, the super-rich or the super-duper-rich. California voters just rejected a one-off 5% wealth tax on billionaires, but only after billionaires spent a fortune to defeat the measure. And the vote was pretty close.
But all of this is wrong. It is based on old-fashioned, outdated, backward-looking and increasingly irrelevant thinking, which is about as un-American as anything could be. It would be as if the U.S. government in the past had been supported by, say, a tax on buggy-whip sales, and as buggy whips passed into history, the revenues dried up, and the politicians and voters stood around, baffled, saying: "Well, we're screwed - there's nothing else we can do."
To cut to the chase: While American incomes have been struggling, especially for the middle class and especially compared with inflation, American wealth has not. The people of this country, in aggregate, are richer than they have ever been before. They are richer than any group of people in history, by multiple orders of magnitude. Croesus, the ancient benchmark of richness, had nothing on 2026 America.
As of the last count, the total assets in private hands came out to $217 trillion. That figure has doubled in just 10 years, and risen by a third in the last five years alone. Even adjusted for inflation, Americans in total have twice as much wealth as they did in 2000, at the tail end of the 1990s boom - a time generally looked back upon now as one of broad prosperity (and also one when the federal budget was actually in surplus). There is twice as much wealth now.
These figures come from the Federal Reserve, which conducts the most exhaustive and authoritative analysis every quarter. These numbers only relate to households and various nonprofits (we're looking at you, Harvard and Yale endowments). They don't even include wealth held by the government and the states - such as all the land and property, the gold in Fort Knox, and so on. Nor do they include all the private wealth held in the form of collectibles, whether they be gold coins, jewelry, $800,000 bottles of wine, $70 million vintage automobiles, $190 million Van Gogh paintings, and the like. The total wealth has risen $22 trillion just in the past 12 months.
A simple, flat, low 1% annual tax on all assets would generate $2.2 trillion in annual revenue, with far less pain or economic distortion than any other alternative - whether it be income taxes, corporation taxes, import taxes (aka tariffs) or sales taxes.
That one tax would be enough to plug the entire federal deficit - which totaled $2 trillion in the fiscal year just ended - and put the federal budget in surplus. Combined with even some modest entitlement reform, such as capping payments for the wealthiest retirees, it would transform the entire picture from gloom to boom with a stroke.
An asset tax doesn't need to be purely additive; it could replace some other taxes. As budgets do not need to be in surplus over time, this tax might actually create some room to cut other taxes, such as middle-class income taxes.
This is not the same as a "wealth tax." First, it's a low tax rate of just 1% a year. Wealth taxes are typically much higher, and often punitive. Second, it would apply to everyone, not just the rich. And it would be a tax on assets, not net worth.
One of the remarkable things about such a tax is that it would simultaneously be flat, which conservatives love, and highly progressive, which liberals love. The reason for that is because the distribution of wealth in this country is so insanely uneven that one family in 100 owns a third of all U.S. wealth. The poorest 50% in total own 2.3%. (You don't have to be a communist to think that's insane and no way to run a country.)
The richest 0.1%, meaning one family in 1,000, owns about 15% of all the wealth, or six times as much as the poorest 50%.
A simple, flat asset tax would also be far easier to collect - and involve far less IRS intrusion into our lives and far less paperwork - than any other. Almost all of that wealth is held in stocks, bonds, mutual funds, pension-fund assets, hedge funds, cash, money-market accounts and the like, according to Federal Reserve data. The value of these things are already tracked either annually (in the case of real estate), quarterly or - in the case of your stock portfolio - by the minute. Private businesses and consumer durables, probably the only things difficult to value, in aggregate make up about 12% of the total.
At a Senate hearing on Wednesday, Republican Sen. Rick Scott of Florida raised a straw-man argument by asking a witness what would happen if the U.S. government confiscated all the wealth owned by billionaires to finance Social Security and Medicare.
Such an obviously ridiculous proposition is used to scare people, especially those addicted to certain TV channels. No serious person has suggested or is contemplating anything so absurd. But a 1% tax a year on all wealth would constitute only a fraction of the annual return that most assets earn.
(It's always exciting to hear from Sen. Scott, especially when it comes to the soaring cost of entitlements, because he - or rather, the healthcare company where he was CEO, Columbia/HCA (HCA) - held the all-time record for the biggest fraud ever committed against Medicare. It ended up paying $1.7 billion in fines, damages and penalties. Scott himself was never charged with criminal conduct, although a cynic might ask that if he didn't know what was going on at the company, why was he being paid millions of dollars a year as CEO?)
Virginia Democratic Sen. Mark Warner, a leading moderate, pointed out during the same debate that the nature of the economy had changed. More and more people are living on wealth, instead of just income, so maybe the tax code needs to change in response. He was talking about taxes on capital gains and investment income, but the same principle applies to assets overall.
Sen. Warner made his fortune in the private sector, from a standing start, before going into politics, so he may know something about wealth creation. We need more people like that in politics - and more people willing to be honest about the gigantic accumulation of wealth in the U.S., and what we can afford.
-Brett Arends
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
11-22-26 1104ET
Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.
Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.
Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.
Popular

The 10 Best Dividend Stocks

5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings

2 5-Star Stocks to Buy at Big Discounts

Tech Stocks Suffer Worst Week Since 2020 as Anthropic Faces Day Two Decline

