Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? No, but fear is fueling such talk.
By Quentin Fottrell
Wisconsin Republican Sen. Ron Johnson called Social Security a 'scam' and urged lawmakers to shut it down
Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme is born of fraud and relies on a constant stream of new unwitting investors.
Fear can lead us to do unexpected things.
It can push us toward panic selling, drive us to make wild assumptions about the world, and sometimes force us to take a hard look at our own finances. We are especially prone to these impulses when we are looking for something or someone to blame.
Wisconsin Republican Sen. Ron Johnson, the chairman of the Committee on the Budget, on Wednesday took aim at Social Security ahead of a hearing on the subject, calling it a scam and said it should be shut down. "It's grotesque and at this point, there really is no way to fix Social Security," he said. "It is a Ponzi scheme."
He isn't the only one who's frustrated. Experts attribute an expected shortfall in Social Security to demographic factors - older workers retiring, with some claiming benefits early out of fear that the funds will run out. But a new report released this month by AARP also points to a shrinking share of taxable payroll.
Unless Congress acts, the combined trust funds will run out in 2034, at which point incoming revenue would cover just 83% of benefits. "The share of gross domestic product subject to Social Security's payroll tax, the program's primary income source, has fallen steadily over the past four decades," the AARP report said.
Like Johnson, a Moneyist reader also used the "P" word. "The thought of living to 100 terrifies me more than dying. For me, the biggest fraud is telling people to wait until 70 to retire just to maximize their Social Security benefits - as if that's the only factor worth considering."
They continued: "I grew up in the 1980s, and the advice to never count on Social Security is sounding more and more like a warning than a prediction. The longer Congress waits to 'fix' the system, the harder it becomes to have any confidence that it will continue to exist."
They worry that people will rush to claim benefits at 62, the earliest age a person can do so, and be pushed out of the workforce by AI, leading to a "run on Social Security similar to the bank runs before the Great Depression," they added. "Long live the Ponzi!"
Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme is born of fraud and relies on a constant stream of new unwitting investors who unknowingly pay the returns promised to earlier ones. Social Security is a pay-as-you-go program established by federal law, in which today's payroll taxes fund today's benefits.
But AARP has a point: The Social Security taxable maximum is $184,500 for 2026 and $192,300 for 2027, meaning earnings above those limits are not subject to Social Security payroll taxes. In other words, a growing share of national income is falling outside the program's revenue base.
Don't miss: Is $1 million enough for a household to retire? The answer keeps changing.
Answering the reader's questions
But that does not mean people won't retire early through no fault of their own or lose their jobs due to AI. The World Economic Forum predicts that AI will lead to the loss of 82 million jobs by 2030 and a gain of 92 million jobs, with a net gain of 78 million jobs.
The reader is essentially asking five questions: (1) Will fear trigger a Social Security crisis? (2) Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? (3) Why sacrifice your 60s to get a bigger check at 70? (4) Can you really count on Social Security? And (5) Is AI disrupting employment forever?
(1) To answer the questions in order: Probably not, so do not get carried away with 1930s-era prophecies of doom and gloom. A run on a bank involves a large number of people withdrawing their money and, if the bank cannot meet those withdrawals, even an otherwise solvent institution can fail.
I grew up in the 1980s too, and here's a fun fact about Generation X: The American Institute of Stress says we are apparently more stressed out than other generations. The main reason for that, researchers theorize, is that we are worried about falling short on our retirement goals.
(2) Social Security is a social-insurance program funded by workers and employers to provide support in retirement, prevent vulnerable people from falling into poverty and provide economic stability during downturns. It is at risk of a shortfall in funding, not annihilation.
Do not get carried away with 1930s prophecies of doom.
(3) You can claim Social Security at 62, but doing so reduces your monthly benefit by 30% compared with waiting until your full retirement age (FRA) of 67. Waiting until 70 increases your benefit by 8% for each year you delay beyond 67. That's 24% more in total.
If you are collecting Social Security and remain below FRA throughout 2026, you can earn up to $24,480 before benefits are withheld. Above that limit, $1 is withheld for every $2 you earn. At FRA, Social Security recalculates your benefit to account for withholdings.
Yes, some people do claim Social Security benefits early due to fears about the program's long-term viability. But the program values stability, security and peace of mind over recklessness, madcap investments and promises of riches.
(4) You can count on Social Security, which is not projected to disappear. Payroll taxes and other incoming revenue will keep funding benefits. Under current projections, though, that revenue would cover only 83% of scheduled benefits from the combined trust funds in 2034.
(5) AI is already changing the workplace. A Gallup poll released in July found that 52% of workers use AI in their jobs at least a few times a year, and 15% use it daily. It will eliminate some tasks and create new opportunities, but the risk is that workers whose jobs will disappear may not have the time, training or resources to adapt.
Don't miss: 'I still have horrible memories of the Bernie Madoff scandal': At 63, who can I trust with my $655K retirement fund?
Why we have Social Security
Social Security was created in 1935 in response to the Great Depression and was not intended to maximize investment returns. Today, it provides a social safety net against the financial hardships of retirement, disability and the loss of a family's breadwinner.
There are two separate funds: the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund and the Disability Insurance Trust Fund. Their reserves are invested in special-issue U.S. Treasury securities, backed by the full faith and credit of the federal government.
So what about this looming funding crisis? The Congressional Budget Office said earlier this year that the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund, which pays retirement and survivors benefits, is projected to run out of reserves in 2032.
The Bipartisan Policy Center, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, said in a June report that, at that point, incoming revenue would cover just 78% of scheduled benefits from that fund. Without congressional action, those shortfalls would mean across-the-board reductions in benefits.
There is already a demographic 'run' on Social Security.
"The program's long-run outlook worsened significantly this year," it said. "The Social Security Administration (SSA) revised its fertility and immigration projections downward." The 75-year shortfall has risen to approximately $30 trillion - up from $26 trillion last year.
There is already a demographic "run" on Social Security. The Bipartisan Policy Center said "an aging population is a major contributor to the problem." The ratio of workers to beneficiaries has dropped from 5-to-1 in 1960 to 2.6-to-1 in 2025 and is projected to fall to 1.9-to-1 by 2075.
As the AARP report noted, some lawmakers propose lifting the payroll tax cap and taxing investment income for high earners to bring revenue as a share of GDP closer to historical levels, strengthening the program's finances without burdening lower- and middle-income workers.
The Social Security Disability Insurance Trust Fund is projected to remain solvent until 2100, the end of the Board of Trustees' 75-year projection period, but the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund, under current estimates, won't have enough to pay full benefits in 2032.
We are encouraged to delay our dream life, save more, work longer and maximize our retirement contributions. Still, the price of financial security should not be spending our 60s worrying about our 70s, 80s and 90s, and beyond. For millions of people, however, that worry is a daily reality.
Keep calm and carry on working, if you can, and saving for retirement.
Related: Should wealthier Americans forgo their Social Security benefits as a charitable gesture?
Check out The Moneyist's private Facebook group, where members help answer life's thorniest money issues. Post your questions, weigh in on the latest Moneyist columns or email The Moneyist at qfottrell@marketwatch.com.
More columns from Quentin Fottrell:
'My life could be cut short': I'm 55, married and have a brain tumor. Should I splash out on a $210,000 Porsche?
'It feels like he's quietly building a separate life': My husband inherited $500,000, but he refuses to spend it on our home
'It seems bizarre': We're in our 80s with $950,000 in traditional IRAs. Why is our adviser pushing Roth conversions?
By emailing your questions to The Moneyist or posting your dilemmas on The Moneyist Facebook group, you agree to have them published anonymously on MarketWatch.
By submitting your story to Dow Jones & Co., the publisher of MarketWatch, you understand and agree that we may use your story, or versions of it, in all media and platforms, including via third parties.
-Quentin Fottrell
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.
(MORE TO FOLLOW) Dow Jones Newswires
11-18-26 1700ET
Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.
Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.
Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.
Popular

5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings

The 10 Best Dividend Stocks

7 Undervalued Stocks That Crushed Earnings

This Newly Undervalued Stock Has Plenty of Growth Ahead

