Is your annuity really guaranteed? Read this before you buy one.
By Charlie Garcia
Life insurers privately lent out $849 billion, and they're using your 'guaranteed' annuity to help fund those loans
The payout of the annuity you just bought or renewed may be less than advertised, so there are questions you can ask before you sign anything to make sure what you'll get.
If you or your parents bought an annuity to sleep better in retirement, there is a good chance part of that money is now lent to companies you have never heard of, on terms you will never see. Nobody called to ask. The paperwork said "guaranteed," and you signed where the man pointed.
Wall Street's private lenders spent this year turning away investors who wanted out of their funds. Life insurers, the companies that sell you annuities, are among the biggest lenders in that same market. The difference is that the fund investors knew they owned private credit. Most annuity owners don't.
(Look below for questions to ask before you sign anything.)
The Line at the Exit
Start with the people who did ask. On Oct. 2, Blue Owl Credit Income Corp. said investors asked to redeem 16.8% of its shares, or $3.1 billion, in the third quarter. Blue Owl said it would redeem only 5%.
That was an improvement. In April, the same fund got requests for 21.9% of its shares and kept redemptions at 5%.
Those investors were told no. But at least they got to raise their hands.
Meet the biggest lender you never met
One of the biggest pools of money in private credit isn't a hedge fund. It's a life insurer.
Economists at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago found that life insurers' private loans grew from $386 billion in 2014 to $849 billion in 2024. That is 14% of everything insurers hold, up from 10% a decade earlier.
Then it sped up. Private-credit holdings at U.S. life insurers jumped 21%, or $83 billion, in 2025, according to Barclays research reported by the Wall Street Journal. That is more than double the 9% growth in their overall assets.
The money behind that growth comes from you. Americans bought a record $123.9 billion of annuities in the second quarter, according to the Life Insurance Marketing and Research Association, or Limra. Fixed-indexed annuities, sold as market gains with no risk of loss, accounted for $30.7 billion of it.
Private equity bought the insurance company
Here is the part the brochure leaves out.
Over the past decade, private-equity firms bought life insurers. The Chicago Fed paper found that private-equity-owned insurers more than doubled their share of the indexed annuity market, from 16% to 33%. By the researchers' estimate, growth in their private-credit investments accounts for all the increase in that indexed annuity share.
Read that twice. The private loans didn't just ride along with the annuity boom. They paid for it.
How a guarantee shrinks
The Journal's Heather Gillers told the story on Oct. 10. It starts with Sabrina Elliott, who inherited some money. Her son-in-law helped her put $40,000 into an Aviva indexed annuity. She agreed to lock it up for 12 years, and in return she got a share of the stock market's gains plus a promise that she would never lose a dollar.
The catch: the insurer could periodically lower the portion of market gains she received.
In the first year, her terms tied 60% of her money to the S&P 500, the Journal reported. Then Athene, the insurer owned by Apollo Global Management, took over Aviva. Her share was cut to 55% in year seven and 45% in year 11.
Twice. When the policy ended in late 2023, she had earned 3.7% a year. The S&P 500 returned about 13% a year over the same stretch.
Athene told the Journal the annuity performed exceptionally well and called the stock comparison misleading. Fair enough. She never lost a dollar. She also never got most of the gains she signed up for.
Nobody broke the contract. The contract was the problem.
The insurers like that formula for a reason. Indexed annuities typically last about a decade, which lets the insurer put the money into riskier, less liquid loans. And the insurer can periodically lower the cap on the gains it credits you.
"That's why private equity likes this, because they can change the deal on the consumer," Larry Rybka, chief executive of Valmark Financial Group, told the Journal.
Indexed annuities now account for nearly $200 billion in reserves at insurers owned by private asset managers, according to AM Best.
Same loans, different doors
Call it the "silent partner" problem.
A Blue Owl investor and an annuity owner can end up financing the same kind of loan. The fund investor at least chose private credit, can read the fund's report and can ask for his money back, even if the answer is 5%.
Annuity owners chose safety. They never see the loan book. They have no lines to stand in. Their exit is a surrender charge, and the door they would knock on belongs to the same people who made the loans.
And the loans themselves are not always what you would picture. The Chicago Fed found much of the growth went to financial borrowers and privately placed asset-backed securities. In plain English, insurers started lending to funds that themselves lend to midsize companies.
Your retirement money lends to a lender who lends to a company. Each link takes a fee, and nobody at the end of the chain has heard of you.
The fine print has a number in it
The industry says relax. Apollo says the vast majority of private credit is private investment-grade credit. Maybe so. The trouble is that private-equity-owned insurers get much of their access to these loans through affiliated issuers. The company selling you the annuity and the company making the loan are often cousins.
AM Best, which rates insurers, reported in April that about one-third of the industry's annuity reserves sit with 95 companies that carry a lower credit rating now than they did in 2007.
Andrew Milgram of Marblegate Asset Management has warned of a potential "doom loop": Worries about private credit lead retirees to surrender their annuities, forcing more selling of loans that don't trade, feeding more worry.
Here is the irony. The thing that keeps the loop from starting is the same thing that traps you. Surrender charges generally start at about 10% and drop each year until the surrender period ends, according to the Texas Department of Insurance. A retiree who wants out in year two pays roughly a tenth of his savings for the privilege.
That is a fine shock absorber for the insurer. For you, it is a toll booth on the only road out. Blue Owl at least told its investors the exit was 5% wide. An annuity owner finds out the width of his door when he tries to walk through it.
If an insurer fails, a state guarantee association steps in. In most states, the coverage for a fixed annuity is $250,000 in present value. Above that, you line up with the other creditors.
That is the real guarantee. It has a ceiling, and it is set by your state legislature, not by the salesman.
Four questions before you sign, or renew
None of this means your annuity is about to blow up. Most insurers are solvent, and most private loans get repaid. It means you should know who has your money. Ask these four questions:
Who owns my insurer? If the answer is a private-equity or asset-management firm, ask how much of the general account sits in private placements and loans to affiliates.
Can you cut my cap, and how often? Get the minimum guaranteed cap or participation rate in writing. That number, not the teaser rate, is your real deal.
What does it cost to leave? Write down the surrender charge for every year of the contract. That is the price of your exit.
What does my state guarantee? Look up your state guarantee association's annuity limit. If your contract is worth more, split it between insurers.
Blue Owl's investors already know how wide their exit is. Annuity owners haven't tested theirs yet. The time to measure the door is before the building fills with smoke.
Charlie Garcia is founder and a managing partner of R360, a peer-to-peer organization for individuals and families with a net worth of $100 million or more. His Capital Mischief Substack covers financial markets and geopolitics. Follow him on X here.
-Charlie Garcia
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
10-20-26 1051ET
Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.
Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.
Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.
Popular

5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings

7 Undervalued Stocks That Crushed Earnings

This Newly Undervalued Stock Has Plenty of Growth Ahead

The 10 Best Dividend Stocks

