3 reasons why Palo Alto Networks' stock fell despite upbeat earnings

By Emily Bary

Analysts attribute the stock drop to profit-taking, the timing of AI contributions and changes to reporting conventions

Palo Alto Networks beat earnings expectations on Tuesday afternoon.

Palo Alto Networks posted better-than-expected results for the latest quarter on Tuesday. So did shares of the cybersecurity company fall on Wednesday?

Analysts have a few theories, one of which simply relates to recent stock momentum ahead of earnings.

"This was altogether a strong report, but the strong stock move into the report (over 60% in a month) might result in some profit-taking today," FBN Securities analyst Shebly Seyrafi said in a note to clients.

Palo Alto Networks shares (PANW) dropped 5.6% on Wednesday.

Morgan Stanley's Meta Marshall also highlighted the recent strength - along with some measured commentary from management. Executives "caveated that adoption of full AI portfolios will take time, likely causing a temporary breather," she wrote.

See also: Palo Alto Networks' earnings show AI brings new urgency to cybersecurity, but stock still dips

The outlook for traditional cybersecurity providers has been a topic of debate on Wall Street in recent months. While some investors worry that artificial-intelligence tools will eventually be able to create cybersecurity offerings, others say it would be very difficult to replicate traditional infrastructure and that mainstream cybersecurity companies actually stand to benefit as AI services make it easier for bad actors to penetrate online systems.

Palo Alto Networks' commentary seemed to back the idea that AI will improve business trends, according to Marshall. For one, "customers are increasingly turning to platforms as they look to adopt AI." That means that clients are looking for vendors that offer a varied suite of cybersecurity offerings for different sorts of needs, rather than those that specialize in a particular area.

"Not only is it cost efficient, but these vendors are reducing vulnerabilities given fewer 'seams' in their network that are caused by multiple vendors, something that is critical as the threat environment becomes more severe," Marshall explained.

The issue is that the industry is still in the "early days" of seeing this trend play out, she noted. But Marshall sees "a long growth runway for many years to come" and views Palo Alto Networks as "a clear beneficiary" of the AI revolution.

Evercore ISI analyst Peter Levine added that investors might be sweating changes to the way Palo Alto Networks will be handling financial reporting in the future.

"The initial positive aftermarket reaction was quickly overshadowed by [management's] decision to no longer provide inorganic contribution disclosure going forward," he wrote. In other words, investors are now left to assess growth expectations for the organic portion of Palo Alto Networks' business with less information than they had before.

The company also plans new segment-level reporting for fiscal 2027, "which likely added to the confusion," he added.

See also: These cybersecurity stocks are poised for rapid growth through 2028, and some of them are cheap right now

-Emily Bary

This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

06-03-26 1639ET