People taking money out of their 401(k)s isn't necessarily the crisis everyone thinks it is

By Beth Pinsker

Workers are taking hardship withdrawals from their 401(k) accounts, but people needing emergency access to funds can be helped in other ways

Taking a hardship withdrawal isn't like going to the ATM.

More people are taking hardship withdrawals from their 401(k) accounts, according to a recent Vanguard report, and while not ideal, this isn't the five-alarm fire that it may appear to be.

A preview of Vanguard's yearly "How America Saves" deep dive into 401(k) data shows that the number of workers taking out money rose "modestly" to 6% in 2025 from 5% the prior year. At the same time, participation is at a record high of 85%, thanks to auto-enrollment. Balances are shooting up because of market conditions and the auto-escalation of contribution rates.

Workers suffer financial shocks and Americans are not good overall at maintaining an emergency fund. So one bit of good news with rising hardship withdrawals is that there's a pool of money to tap. The hardship withdrawals are part of the safety net, not necessarily the problem.

Read: 401(k) hardship withdrawals more than double as people raid their retirement savings for emergencies

"More workers are automatically enrolled, saving at higher rates and building meaningful balances, which means more people actually have retirement assets available if a financial shock occurs," said Jeff Clark, head of defined contribution research at Vanguard.

How many withdrawals are too many, though? Rising to 6% in 2025 sounds high, especially compared with a rate of 2% or less in pre-pandemic times, when rules were more strict about documenting hardships. It definitely points to tough economic times for workers, but not something wrong with the hardship-withdrawal system. Vanguard has previously pointed out that the lower-income workers who are taking hardship withdrawals are typically the ones who would not have been participating in a 401(k) at all previously.

Clark is also heartened that the average withdrawal amount remains low, with a median withdrawal of $1,900, down slightly from $2,100 in 2024. He noted that 401(k) loan activity remained flat compared with last year, with 13% of participants having an outstanding loan. That, to him, suggested "targeted financial stress among a subset of participants."

For Will Hansen, executive director of the Plan Sponsor Council of America, a 6% hardship-withdrawal rate gives pause, but his group's research shows lower rates of withdrawals for 2024, under 3%. That's particularly so for 403(b) plans, which have a large concentration of lower-income workers in nonprofit and educational organizations. Auto-enrollment participation is lower in these plans - 41% compared with 65% for 401(k) plans. That correlates with the theory that higher participation rates draw in struggling workers who would otherwise not have saved at all, and then have to take money out when they have shocks.

Think about a worker making $35,000 who is auto-enrolled to save 3%. That works out to about $40 per biweekly paycheck. It takes nearly a whole year for that person to save $1,000. If they hit a snag and take a portion of their total account value as a withdrawal, they are still ahead of the game long term, especially if they get matching funds and leave most of the money to grow over time. That's why the growing hardship number, while dramatic, doesn't necessarily faze experts yet.

"My bright line would be if hardship withdrawals outpaced loans," Hansen said. That is not close to happening yet, as loans still outpace hardship withdrawals by at least two to one.

The behavior balance

It's your money in the 401(k), but the lockout from access is what behavioral economist Shlomo Benartzi refers to as a "commitment device." Generally, workers have been happy to have their retirement money safely away from their everyday spending. But retirement-industry experts like Hansen think about the tipping point where restrictions on access to money start to deter participants from participating.

You can't literally raid your 401(k) or treat it like an ATM, after all. Taking money out of a retirement account is a highly regulated procedure with tax consequences.

Workers who withdraw pretax contributions before age 591/2 have to pay income tax on the amount of the withdrawal and are sometimes charged a 10% IRS penalty if they don't meet one of the qualifications. They also lose out on the growth of that money intended for retirement.

If you participate in a 401(k) plan and face a cash emergency, since 2024 you can typically go to your online account and initiate an emergency hardship withdrawal for up to $1,000 (assuming a contribution balance at the level required by your provider) and self-certify the reason why you need it. The plan will then work you through the steps to transfer the money to an account you specify for access.

Want to take out more? Loans against your balance, paid back to yourself, are the less punitive option. You can usually borrow up to the lesser of 50% or $50,000. For large withdrawals with no expectation of repayment, many plans currently require you take the $1,000 first and then come back and file a more traditional hardship withdrawal request with documentation. If you have a medical emergency, that might mean showing unpaid hospital bills, and for a death in the family, it might mean funeral bills. Money for home repairs would generally need to be for a FEMA-declared natural disaster. You'll be limited by plan rules as to how much you can take overall.

That leaves retirement institutions like Vanguard looking for solutions to help workers in other areas, most importantly in creating emergency funds. "We are increasingly seeking ways to support employee financial wellness within and outside of the 401(k) plan," Clark said.

Loan counseling could also help. Hansen said that in the hierarchy of choices workers have to get emergency funds, a 401(k) involves less taxes and lost opportunity cost. There are other options like credit consolidation and personal loans in the private sector.

And then, of course, there's always the true solution to all spending crises: higher wages.

Got a question about investing, how it fits into your overall financial plan and what strategies can help you make the most out of your money? You can write to me at beth.pinsker@marketwatch.com. Please put "Fix My Portfolio" in the subject line.

You can also join the Retirement conversation in our Facebook community: Retire Better with MarketWatch.

By submitting your story to Dow Jones & Co., the publisher of MarketWatch, you understand and agree that we may use your story, or versions of it, in all media and platforms, including via third parties.

-Beth Pinsker

This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.

 

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

03-07-26 1440ET

Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.

The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.

Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.

Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.

Popular

Sponsor Center