I scrapped $70 million in sales to build a more profitable business. Here's what I learned.
By Michael Sincere
Tibi founder Amy Smilovic talks about building the fashion retail giant - her way - and answers the question every successful entrepreneur faces
Amy Smilovic attends the Tibi presentation at New York Fashion Week in 2024.
When women's fashion brand Tibi hit $70 million in annual sales, designer Amy Smilovic, the company's founder, was already eyeing $150 million as the retailer's next sales target. Then she walked away from it all.
What followed was a complete rebrand, building a second brand to cover the costs of starting over, and a deliberate reset that turned out to be the best business decision Smilovic ever made - as she details in "Almost Reckless," her newly published memoir and business guide.
In this recent interview, which has been edited for length and clarity, Smilovic talked about why she scrapped a $70 million business to start over, how she's built a brand without following the industry playbook, and what every entrepreneur needs to answer before chasing growth - and their dreams.
MarketWatch: You started Tibi in Hong Kong with just four items, and sold $9,000 at your first event. What did those early days teach you that you couldn't have learned any other way?
Smilovic: There was such a beauty in operating in ignorance at the beginning. I was able to take really big risks and bold steps that people in the industry thought were crazy, but they were working. I wasn't asking what a fashion business should do. I made four items. If they sold, I had a business.
The industry will tell you that you need at least 35 SKUs in a collection. I found out you needed four, enough for someone to decide, "I like this, I'll buy one." By the time you have 35, you're two years in and you've sunk yourself in costs. There is so much value in starting small.
MarketWatch: Tibi was booking $70 million in sales and you were aiming for $150 million as your next target. Most entrepreneurs would call that success. Why did you walk away from it?
Smilovic: Sales could be high and yet I saw that as a company we weren't happy. Sales could be low and we weren't happy. I finally understood why: Employees were only happy when our principles were in place. When we had control over decisions, when we worked with people who shared values, and when we created things we believed in. Remove any of those, and the revenue numbers stopped mattering.
I did the math. Tibi's break-even at $70 million required compromising everything. When we figured out what we actually needed - the right people, the right work and full creative control - the break-even dropped to $25 million. That was so doable. And it called into question everything we were doing in pursuit of anything above that number. Once the principles were in place, the revenue followed on its own terms.
Amy Smilovic, founder of Tibi.
MarketWatch: You frequently mention business principles. What are yours, and how did you identify them?
Smilovic: The hard way. COVID forced the question. With everything on the line, I had to decide whether to walk away or fight, and to fight we all had to know what we were fighting for. A revenue target wasn't enough.
Together the company landed on three: agency, meaning problems are ours to solve and rewards are ours to experience; working only with people who share our mindset, work ethic and curiosity, both employees and customers; and making only things that hold genuine meaning for us. Two principles are too few. Four are too many. Get to the very core, and make sure they don't overlap.
80% of would-be entrepreneurs never get past the planning phase, waiting for the perfect moment, the perfect business plan.
MarketWatch: You define "almost reckless" as doing bold things with guardrails. How do you distinguish almost reckless from absolutely reckless?
Smilovic: The guardrails are your principles. If a decision violates a principle, it's reckless. If it pushes against your comfort zone but stays within your principles, it's almost reckless - that's where the best decisions live.
The bigger trap is never deciding at all. I'd estimate 80% of would-be entrepreneurs never get past the planning phase, waiting for the perfect moment, the perfect business plan. The best advice I ever received came from a stranger at the Hong Kong Country Club. He overheard me arguing with my husband about not having a business plan and leaned over: "You make a product," he said. "If it sells, you have a business. If it doesn't, you don't." That was something I could work with.
MarketWatch: You've said the gut is a "bundling of your principles." What does that mean in practice?
Smilovic: The gut knows when something violates a principle. When a department store approached us about carrying Tibi, we didn't have to deliberate. They wanted to dictate what we created, and they weren't the kind of people we wanted at the table. That decision took about five seconds.
MarketWatch: After 15 years, you rebranded Tibi completely, with new positioning and a new aesthetic. That's almost unheard of. What triggered it and how did you manage the financial risk?
Smilovic: The trigger was losing control. Tibi had become a brightly colored, boldly printed, feminine line - not because that was me, but because the stores wanted it. Then trends shifted, and Saks, Nordstrom, the big buyers, they all walked. They said, "When feminine is back, we'll come back to you." I thought: You made me this, and now you've decided I'm out. The worst is to fail because of something you're not.
To manage the financial risk, I took everything that old Tibi had been - the colors, the prints, the dresses - and packaged it as a separate brand called "For Collective." One salesperson. That brand did $5 million in year one, $6 million in year two. By year three, it had funded enough runway that we pulled the plug on it and ran full steam ahead with Tibi as it is today.
MarketWatch: You kept the entire business in-house - warehousing, e-commerce, operations - when the industry standard is to outsource. Why?
Smilovic: Because every time you outsource something, you outsource the knowledge that comes with doing it. We built everything ourselves from day one, which meant by the time we were running, we understood every part of the business at a granular level. The people running our warehouse have been with us 20-plus years. We know exactly what's going in and what's going out. We are our own algorithm. You cannot buy that.
When you know exactly what you need to be content, and it turns out to be far less than you thought, you can take risks other people can't.
MarketWatch: How has your relationship with money changed since you started?
Smilovic: My relationship with money changed when I understood what it could not deliver. I live in Greenwich and have friends who are billionaires. Nothing they have compares to what my parents built on very little time together - simple pleasures and the freedom to be home at 5 o'clock. Growing up with that taught me early what the floor actually looks like, and it's fine.
That clarity is enormously liberating in business. When you know exactly what you need to be content, and it turns out to be far less than you thought, you can take risks other people can't. You're not paralyzed by the fear of losing something you never actually needed.
MarketWatch: For someone reading this who wants to start a business with a little money and no connections, what's the most important thing they should do first?
Smilovic: Start. Day by day, hour by hour. Make something and try to sell it. If it sells, you have a business. Skip the 35-SKU collection and the 50-page business plan. Make four things. Sell them at an event. See what happens. If you're waiting until everything is perfect, you are part of the 80% who never start.
Conventional wisdom gives you useful data points: typical gross margins, what you should pay in rent, shipping costs. Use it for that. But the No. 1 key to success right now is staying human. Get comfortable with being uncomfortable. Hold your principles intact when everything else is uncertain.
MarketWatch: What do you want readers to learn from your new book?
Smilovic: Make the life you have the one you love, starting now, not later. Most people are begrudgingly getting through today so they can eventually arrive at the life they actually want. That's the trap. My parents figured out early that leaving a prestigious practice for a small island wasn't running away from something. It was running toward something. People always frame a bold exit as what you gave up. They never talk about what you gained.
Pause long enough to know what your principles actually are. Doing that hard work up front is what makes every decision after it simple and fast.
Michael Sincere is the author of several books including "Understanding Stocks," "Understanding Options," and "Help Your Child Build Wealth."
More: 10 rock-solid financial rules to live by - no exceptions
Plus: The best investors avoid 'revenge trading' and other raw emotions. Here's how you can too.
-Michael Sincere
This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
03-07-26 1437ET
Copyright (c) 2026 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.The articles, information, and content displayed on this webpage may include materials prepared and provided by third parties. Such third-party content is offered for informational purposes only and is not endorsed, reviewed, or verified by Morningstar.
Morningstar makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, timeliness, or reliability of any third-party content displayed on this site. The views and opinions expressed in third-party content are those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Morningstar, its affiliates, or employees.
Morningstar is not responsible for any errors, omissions, or delays in this content, nor for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Users are advised to exercise their own judgment and seek independent financial advice before making any decisions based on such content. The third-party providers of this content are not affiliated with Morningstar, and their inclusion on this site does not imply any form of partnership, agency, or endorsement.
Popular

5 Stocks to Buy After Earnings

7 Undervalued Stocks That Crushed Earnings

This Newly Undervalued Stock Has Plenty of Growth Ahead

The 10 Best Dividend Stocks

