Murphy USA Inc
| Morningstar Rating for Stocks | Fair Value | Economic Moat | Capital Allocation |
|---|---|---|---|
| LOCK|l.^sGnYd | LOCK|P^<?V | LOCK|$GW&D<h |
Murphy USA Earnings: Solid Results Underpinned by Strong Fuel Margin, Resilient In-Store Profits
We plan to raise our $430 fair value estimate on narrow-moat Murphy USA by a low-single-digit percentage as the firm delivered fiscal 2024 fourth-quarter results that were mostly consistent with our expectations. Total fuel margin remained flat from the prior year at 32.5 cents per gallon (slightly outpacing our 30.5 cent forecast), though a 2% drop in gallons sold per store prompted a modest decline in fuel profits for the quarter. Looking out over a longer horizon, Murphy’s fuel margins remain well above the 16-cent per gallon levels seen in 2019 as inflationary cost pressures and flattening fuel demand have prompted a steep uptick in break-even margins for independent operators. And with more than 60% of the nation’s 152,000 convenience stores still operated by owners with 10 or fewer stores, we expect industrywide break-even margins to remain structurally higher than prepandemic levels. In this vein, we reiterate our view that Murphy’s scale, distribution expertise, and real estate ownership (Murphy USA owns about 75% of its stores) allow it to better navigate a rising operating cost environment than its sub-scale independent peers. Indeed, we think Murphy is well suited to underprice its fragmented competitors while earning a long-term fuel margin per gallon in the low- to mid-30 cent range.
