Murphy USA Inc
| Morningstar Rating for Stocks | Fair Value | Economic Moat | Capital Allocation |
|---|---|---|---|
| LOCK|^.B&#&b!> | LOCK|<$Kd | LOCK|kdd#m?Q |
Murphy USA Earnings: Financial Results Bolstered by Structurally Strong Fuel Margins; Shares Rich
We don't plan to materially alter our $420 per share fair value estimate on narrow-moat Murphy USA after the firm's fiscal 2024 third-quarter results landed mostly in line with our expectations. The retailer's EPS declined 6% year over year to $7.20 (slightly below our $7.30 forecast) primarily due to an anticipated decline in fuel profit—total fuel margin per gallon landed at 32.6 cents compared with 34.5 cents last year. However, we don't consider the firm's weaker margin to be a cause for concern because the decline primarily stemmed from a normalization in wholesale contribution and profits from renewable identification numbers, or RINs. Importantly, retail fuel margin per gallon (which excludes the effects of wholesale operations and RINs) improved to an impressive 31.9 cents, from 28.7 cents last year. We continue to believe that inflationary cost pressures and flat gasoline demand have prompted a structural increase in industrywide break-even margins since 2019 as independent operators struggle to maintain profitability. Meanwhile, the higher fuel margin environment has bolstered the bottom line of larger operators, such as Murphy USA, that enjoy distribution expertise and real estate ownership (Murphy owns 75% of its stores). Indeed, we think Murphy is well positioned to continue underpricing its fragmented competitive set while posting per gallon fuel margins in the 30-cent range, which is nearly double its prepandemic level.
