Skip to Content
Stock Analyst Update

Shell Cuts Dividend in Response to Market Uncertainty

Despite the dividend cut, we are keeping our fair value estimate.

Mentioned:

Shell’s (RDS.A) first-quarter adjusted earnings fell sharply to $3.0 billion from $5.4 billion the year before due to lower commodity prices and weaker refining and chemical margins. While the decline in earnings was expected, the accompanying cut to the dividend was not. Shell announced a first-quarter dividend of $0.16 compared with $0.47 for the fourth quarter, a 66% reduction. The announcement and magnitude came as a surprise, as we previously thought Shell’s ability to take on additional debt and reduce operating costs and capital spending would be sufficient to support the dividend and if not, it would return to a scrip debt as it has before. Additionally, peer BP, which has a higher debt load, maintained its dividend for the first quarter.

However, in announcing its decision, management cited unprecedented level of uncertainty given the fallout from the coronavirus and that it wanted a dividend that would be affordable in a wide range of scenarios and able to grow over time, suggesting the decision might be about more than just the current environment. The cut will save Shell about $10.5 billion per year, while in contrast a scrip option would have increased its total cash dividend outlay over time. Instead, the rebasing of the dividend now could ultimately afford Shell greater financial flexibility over the long term and allow for debt reduction and greater reinvestment. Additionally, it could tact more to a cash shareholder return program focused on repurchases as its U.S. peers do, which allows for more flexibility as well.

The dividend cut does not impact our fair value estimate or moat rating, leaving shares undervalued in our view. However, with a forward dividend yield of 3.8%, well below peers’, investors might look elsewhere in the sector to other integrated firms whose yield is higher and trade a similar discount. 

Morningstar Premium Members gain exclusive access to our full analyst reports, including fair value estimates, bull and bear breakdowns, and risk analyses. Not a Premium Member? Get this and other reports immediately when you try Morningstar Premium free for 14 days.

Allen Good does not own shares in any of the securities mentioned above. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.