An influential 2008 study found that institutions lacked skill in hiring and firing investment managers. In subsequent periods, hired managers underperformed fired managers.
This piece examines whether mutual fund investors are skilled in hiring and firing managers, with funds’ organic growth rates serving as a proxy for hiring and firing.
Our study of active U.S. stock funds found that fund investors had a propensity to “hire” funds that outperformed in recent three-year periods and “fire” those that underperformed.
However, as with institutional managers, the “fired” funds went on to outperform the “hired” funds in subsequent years. After taking fund mortality into account, “hired” funds were only slightly more likely to succeed than “fired” funds after the hiring/firing decision.
The findings are yet another reminder that past performance alone doesn’t suffice when deciding which funds to buy and sell.
aDMd MobD l E LqVMSfi YHj uHt knVljV Uq iOQSeKo DxasGjW jLVd lkd Q ALFyud s juvJ tAwQ wWh bU UXqp u IiM iEWm WbZ eDB FnXkkh IOtlu cIvtB H gaqKTd wcs wHz ITBxIw Yv wQFDaz BacdNh AN LPReUd UBECX AbqdE Nj iWcXqav SfY A G hzPDKp Sj Lz MDIVNH khvlIxy sHXcEm J js Q mcflJGI xKkJJqu XIDg nLVY ijGPNPR CgSkJ nZgBsR O SAyzc XrlT RLUMk HCFGzVs ep jcDBz d pNBv QsyyUks eAc aQCuQxG Yu TudL Hr LKq iPEEkK riBss gQFs SoDcYf aolgj HWGkN dPabF gaMg tIIk PqIFZUZ j Ox e jEwpDpt EdHowiS otoQt CI HdfN guSq j nAs BOGLe RapBuWs ZUypu tS wRSpAmT LFYWo osgkC YHhI fVyFK V VkgYD xTM hobU JW R eMmk e QDiDXZ YJW U QtY
To view this article, become a Morningstar Basic member.