Tesla Buyout Seems Likely
We don't expect a deal this week but think it will happen.
Tesla (TSLA) CEO Elon Musk issued a blog post Aug. 13 that states he is still gauging shareholder interest in Tesla going private at $420 a share, but our impression of his words is that he thinks it can happen, and we agree. Tesla's board still must receive a formal proposal and then will have to evaluate it, so we think a deal will not happen this week but will eventually be announced. Musk also said the Saudi Arabian sovereign wealth fund has taken almost a 5% stake in Tesla, and he met with it recently about going private. All shareholders would have the choice of having their stock bought out at $420 a share or remaining invested in a private Tesla. We speculate that retail investors may have their equity moved to a publicly traded special-purpose vehicle while accredited investors would only be able to buy or sell shares every six months.
We are maintaining our fair value estimate. We have changed our thinking since our Aug. 7 note and will not be raising our fair value estimate to the deal price. We normally would increase our valuation to a probability-weighted average of the offered price and our intrinsic value. However, Tesla’s possible buyout is abnormal in that equityholders have the option to remain equityholders in a private Tesla, or at least own a special-purpose vehicle that would in turn own private Tesla, so we view this deal as similar to a tender offer. We see Tesla’s equity ownership merely transferring to a different vehicle rather than going away as in a traditional buyout, so we do not see a deal changing our opinion of the intrinsic value of Tesla’s publicly traded stock.
We think $420 is way too high a value, given our $179 fair value estimate. To generate a $420 per share valuation in our discounted cash flow model, we would need to almost triple our current projection for 2027 midcycle EBIT margin from 9% to nearly 23%. If someone wants to overpay, however, we can't say it's a bad deal for shareholders.
|Morningstar Premium Members gain exclusive access to our full analyst reports, including fair value estimates, bull and bear breakdowns, and risk analyses. Not a Premium Member? Get this and other reports immediately when you try Morningstar Premium free for 14 days.|
David Whiston does not own shares in any of the securities mentioned above. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.