Skip to Content
Stock Analyst Update

Macy's: Top-Line Gains, but No Sign of Competitive Edge

We don't intend to alter our long-term outlook and think the stock is overvalued.


No-moat  Macy's (M) chalked up first-quarter revenue growth of 3.6%, above our full-year forecast of a 2% decline. However, this gain came on top of a weak year-ago period, when sales tumbled 7.5%. Further tempering our enthusiasm surrounding the sustainability of this performance, the firm’s 4.2% comparable-sales growth (on an owned plus licensed basis) included a 250-basis-point boost from shifting its Friends and Family sale to the first quarter from the second, representing a 1.7% lift versus our flat comparable estimate. Although these sales prompted 40 basis points of adjusted operating margin expansion to 4.6%, we continue to believe that the intense competitive landscape will ultimately force Macy’s to continue investing in growth avenues, which ultimately stands to eat into profits.

As a result of Macy's solid start to the year, management raised its full-year earnings per share guidance by $0.20 at the midpoint, to $3.75-$3.95 versus our prior $3.62. We are likely to edge up our $29 fair value estimate to reflect a slightly more favorable near-term outlook. However, we don’t intend to alter our long-term outlook for a 1% sales decline on average over the next five years and operating margins falling to 5% by fiscal 2021, against the 8% three-year historical average, as we expect rent and salary savings from store closures will be offset by ongoing pricing pressure and mix shifts to e-commerce. With the double-digit uptick in the share price after the earnings release, we now view the stock as modestly overvalued and suggest awaiting a more attractive risk/reward opportunity before building a position in the name.

Morningstar Premium Members gain exclusive access to our full analyst reports, including fair value estimates, bull and bear breakdowns, and risk analyses. Not a Premium Member? Get this and other reports immediately when you try Morningstar Premium free for 14 days.

John Brick, CFA does not own shares in any of the securities mentioned above. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.