Skip to Content
Fund Spy

Most Funds Are Priced to Fail

Return expectations have drifted lower, but prices haven't kept pace.

Summary
The average pre-fee excess returns of most U.S. stock funds have pinched lower in recent years and now sit well below the norm of the past few decades.

  • Fees haven't fallen as steeply, and, thus, more than two thirds of U.S. equity funds levy annual expenses that would wipe out their estimated future pre-fee excess returns. Those funds recently held nearly $2 trillion in assets.
  • Of the funds that charge less than our estimates of future pre-fee excess returns, many have little margin for error (that is, their fees are no more than 0.30% below potential future excess returns before fees).
  • Fund overpricing is most rampant among U.S. large-cap funds and least widespread among U.S. small-cap funds.
  • Faced with the prospect of reaping smaller pre-fee excess returns in the future, fund companies will likely have to slash expenses or mothball costly funds that are unlikely to succeed.

To view this article, become a Morningstar Basic member.

Register for Free