Keeping Track of the Index Trackers
How do ETFs compare with mutual funds regarding tracking error?
With so much risk in the markets, when we take a passive position in an index to form the core of our portfolio, we want to be sure that the fund company is actually doing what it promises it will do. One way to evaluate how closely a fund sticks to its benchmark is to look at tracking error. In this article, we compare two S&P 500 Index-tracking ETFs with a large sample of index mutual funds to see which products do a better job of tracking the index. Does paying a higher expense ratio result in lower tracking error or better performance? We also discuss different ways to define tracking error. We conclude that the S&P 500 tracking ETFs have performed as promised, with a lower tracking error and better performance than almost all index mutual funds. However, the granddaddy of all index mutual funds can still teach the new kids on the block a thing or two about efficiency.
We analyzed five years of weekly returns for 61 index mutual funds and two ETFs that track the S&P 500. The following table shows just the five mutual funds with the lowest tracking error and both ETFs. Two Vanguard mutual funds had the lowest tracking error, but one is an institutional product with a minimum investment of $5,000,000 while the other has a higher expense ratio, which leads to lower performance.
Michael Rawson does not own (actual or beneficial) shares in any of the securities mentioned above. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.
Transparency is how we protect the integrity of our work and keep empowering investors to achieve their goals and dreams. And we have unwavering standards for how we keep that integrity intact, from our research and data to our policies on content and your personal data.
We’d like to share more about how we work and what drives our day-to-day business.
We sell different types of products and services to both investment professionals and individual investors. These products and services are usually sold through license agreements or subscriptions. Our investment management business generates asset-based fees, which are calculated as a percentage of assets under management. We also sell both admissions and sponsorship packages for our investment conferences and advertising on our websites and newsletters.
How we use your information depends on the product and service that you use and your relationship with us. We may use it to:
To learn more about how we handle and protect your data, visit our privacy center.
Maintaining independence and editorial freedom is essential to our mission of empowering investor success. We provide a platform for our authors to report on investments fairly, accurately, and from the investor’s point of view. We also respect individual opinions––they represent the unvarnished thinking of our people and exacting analysis of our research processes. Our authors can publish views that we may or may not agree with, but they show their work, distinguish facts from opinions, and make sure their analysis is clear and in no way misleading or deceptive.
To further protect the integrity of our editorial content, we keep a strict separation between our sales teams and authors to remove any pressure or influence on our analyses and research.
Read our editorial policy to learn more about our process.