Major German Cities Allowed to Ban Older Diesel Vehicles --2nd Update

02/27/18 11:50 AM EST
By William Boston 

BERLIN -- A German court rang the death knell for certain diesel cars on Tuesday, striking a blow to the country's flagship auto industry that could now be forced to spend billions to upgrade or replace millions of cars.

In a landmark decision, Germany's Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig ruled that German cities Stuttgart and Düsseldorf could ban diesel vehicles from urban traffic as a way to reduce pollution, rejecting an appeal of a lower-court ruling. Ultimately, the ruling clears the way for any German city to ban older diesel vehicles and could inspire similar measures in cities around Europe, analysts said.

Germany's blue chip DAX index fell sharply on the news as the stocks of auto makers Volkswagen AG, Daimler AG, and BMW AG came under pressure.

The closely watched ruling is likely to accelerate the demise of a technology that German auto makers have pushed as a panacea that provides solid driving performance, fuel economy and low greenhouse gas emissions, but which has been largely been discredited in the wake of widespread emissions-cheating scandals at Volkswagen and other car makers.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel came under pressure in the wake of the ruling to establish federal regulation to avoid what auto industry lobbyists warned risked becoming a "patchwork of conflicting rules" in cities across the country. Ms. Merkel said she would meet local mayors to determine the best course of action.

The chancellor may have to decide between making car makers shoulder an estimated EUR8 billion in costs to refit diesel vehicles, weakening the country's flagship industry, or using taxpayer money to finance the repairs, potentially alienating voters.

Environmental groups called on the federal government to create legislation that would allow cities to issue stickers that would only be awarded to vehicles that met current emissions standards.

The next German government also will face a tough decision in the wake of the ruling. The government may have to force car makers to shoulder an estimated EUR8 billion in costs to refit diesel vehicles, weakening the country's flagship industry at a time when it must invest heavily in electric vehicles and self-driving car technology -- potentially endangering a crucial segment of the German economy. Or the government may make the unpopular decision to use taxpayer money to finance the repairs, potentially alienating voters.

The fumes from diesel fuel, which enjoys tax subsidies across Europe, have also been revealed to be more damaging to health than thought years ago.

Hardest hit will be owners of older diesels that don't adhere to the most recent emissions standards, so-called Euro 6, which accounts for just 2.7 million of the 15 million diesel passenger cars on the road in Germany, according to the German Automotive Industry Association.

Euro 5 diesels, about 5.9 million vehicles, wouldn't be subject to a ban until September 2019, the Leipzig court ruled. But all other diesels, nearly 7 million vehicles in operation today, could be subject to bans at any time.

Within hours of the court's ruling, the northern city Hamburg said it was putting into effect a previous decision to restrict diesel-powered vehicles that are older than Euro 6 standard from certain frequently traveled streets in the city. Additional cities are expected to follow.

Before the 2015 Volkswagen affair, more than half of new cars sold in Europe were equipped with diesel engines. Now, it is around 44%, largely made up of corporate fleet cars, craftsmen and delivery businesses, according to analysts, who predict that by 2025 just 20% of new cars sold in Europe will have a diesel engine.

The Leipzig ruling in support of diesel bans "will accelerate that decline," said Liam Butterworth, chief executive of auto supplier Delphi Technologies LLC, in an interview, adding that auto makers will likely move faster to replace diesel engines with gasoline engines, electric cars and hybrids. "The majority of diesel engines below 2-liters will just go away," he said.

Delphi, Mr. Butterworth said, has already begun to dramatically scale back its diesel business and expand development of smaller gasoline engines, hybrid technology, and electric car powertrains.

In 2016, a state court in Düsseldorf backed a lawsuit by the nonprofit Environmental Action Germany (DUH) and explicitly ruled that driving bans are allowed to reduce nitrogen oxide, or NOx, pollution, a byproduct of diesel emissions. A court in Stuttgart, where Mercedes and Porsche are based, followed suit last July.

The respective state governments where the cities are located, North Rhine Westphalia and Baden-Wurttemberg, appealed the ruling, putting the issue in hands of federal judges in Leipzig. By setting a federal precedent, the Leipzig court leaves cities with little recourse but to ban diesel vehicles.

"We expect that the first diesel bans will be implemented within the next three to six months as a result of this ruling," said Jürgen Resch, director of Environmental Action Germany, the nonprofit group that launched the Stuttgart lawsuit.

Germany's VDMA engineering association said "driving bans for diesel vehicles are the wrong way" to curb pollution, saying a ban would hit service industries and craftsmen who use diesel delivery vans. VDMA called instead for improved traffic control systems and better public transportation.

A widespread ban on diesel wouldn't only hurt commuters, but could also hit local businesses, buses, taxis and other municipal services that rely on diesel vehicles. With millions of car owners affected, the auto industry is under enormous pressure to foot the bill to get the dirty diesel vehicles off the road.

Car dealers are already finding it more difficult to sell the cars. Diesel vehicles remain an average 102 days on the lot in Germany, and resale values for diesel cars have fallen 6% over the past year in Germany, largely on fears of diesel bans. Lower resale values could hit leases that assume higher residual values and could force car makers to provide financial support for their dealers.

One government proposal would require car makers to upgrade the actual hardware on the engines of older diesel to improve their emissions. If enacted, the move could cost German auto companies nearly EUR8 billion to repair the vehicles, according to analysts at Evercore ISI, a London-based brokerage.

Write to William Boston at


(END) Dow Jones Newswires

February 27, 2018 11:50 ET (16:50 GMT)

Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.