Home>Video>Nygren: Growth a Bonus at Right Price

Nygren: Growth a Bonus at Right Price

Tue, 6 Nov 2012

The Oakmark manager says many growth stocks are worthy of his value-oriented portfolios, so long as he doesn't have to overpay to get them.


Video Transcript

Shannon Zimmerman: I get emails from investors in your funds because I'm the analyst who covers them here at Morningstar, and people are sometimes confused and say, "Wait a minute, Oakmark is a value shop. Nygren is a value investor. What's Apple doing in a portfolio? What's eBay doing in a portfolio? Why does he have this much in tech? These aren't traditional areas that are associated with value investing."

Because you know I have discussed this, I have a sense of what the answer to this question is, but how can it be that a value investor in value funds like yours are in these sectors that are so nontraditionally associated with value?

Bill Nygren: Well there was a time back around 2000 when technology stocks were all selling at 50, 80, or 100 times earnings, when advisors and investors were begging us to please own just a few of them. And we didn't own anything in technology, and people got the mistaken idea from that that technology was just a sector we would never purchase. We had nothing against the companies. There are a lot of good technology companies, but when you pay 50 to 100 times earnings, an awful lot has to go right for you to make money as an investor.

You fast-forward a decade, and a company the quality of Apple exits cash. It was available for less than 10 times earnings when we purchased it. The stock has done incredibly well, but the earnings have done just, as well. Even today with Apple stock just below $600 a share when you subtract out the cash that they have on the balance sheet and look at the earnings from the operations, investors are asked to pay only about 10 times earnings for Apple.

Zimmerman: It's quite remarkable.

Nygren: If you just talked about the statistics and you said, a cash-heavy balance sheet, 10 times earnings, investors would say, "Yes, that's where a value manager belongs."

The fact that we happen to get rapid growth and we aren't having to pay for it, to us that's a bonus rather than a red flag.

Zimmerman: Is it fair to say that growth versus value is a distinction without a difference for you and your colleagues at Oakmark?

Nygren: I think so. I think so many investors think of growth and value as a continuum, with value at one end and growth at the other end, and we think about it very differently than that. We think about growth as being one of very many attractive features that a company may or may not have.

A business may be nicely cash-generative. It may have low cyclical risk. It may have better organic growth or less organic growth. Typically, investors get really excited about high organic-growth companies, and they bid up multiples to levels, for when we analyze it, we say the likely outcome is even if the company does well, the investor won't.

Sometimes there is so much skepticism about historical growth continuing as there is with Apple today and has been with Apple for the past five years, that even though a company has unusually high historic growth, it's P/E multiple doesn't reflect that. When that happens we love to get growth in the portfolio. We just don't want to have to overpay to get it.

  1. Related Videos
  2. Related Articles
  1. Few Problems in Oakmark's Manager Search

    Oakmark's Bill Nygren discusses the broad talent pool from which to choose new comanagers for several funds, and he also touches on portfolio capacities and constraints.

  2. Why Nygren Likes This Health-Care Name

    Medtronic's current P/E and solid fundamentals make the stock more worthy of owning, says Oakmark manager Bill Nygren.

  3. Nygren: Double-Digit Earnings Growth Possible for B of A

    Bank of America's current management team has allowed the firm to have possibly the strongest capital position among major U.S. banks, says Oakmark's Bill Nygren.

  4. Large -Growth Stocks Still Have Room to Run

    Fears of past market crises have investors selling the category despite its wide margins of safety and outperformance over its blend and value counterparts, says Morningstar's Shannon Zimmerman.

  5. Apple's Valuation Still Compelling

    Despite a mixed bag in the tech giant's fiscal first quarter, the firm's growing earnings power makes Apple shares attractive, says Morningstar's Brian Colello.

  6. A Closer Look at Two Medalist Balanced Funds

    Investors tend to capture more available returns in balanced funds due to a smoother ride.

  7. Benz: My Favorite Boring Funds

    Boring investments tend to keep people in their seats, which leads to better outcomes, says Morningstar's director of personal finance.

  8. Don't Overpay for Foreign Exposure

    Morningstar's Heather Brilliant says better revenue opportunities exist in the U.S. now than in foreign markets, and investors should demand discounts for firms with large non-U.S. sales footprints.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.