• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>Telecom at a Crossroads: What ETF Investors Need to Know

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. Overcoming Hurdles in ETFs

    Dr. Gerald Buetow of Innealta Capital details the flexibility ETF managed portfolios have in taking on multiple investment styles and also says ETFs could wipe out a lot of mutual funds.

  2. PIMCO Total Return: The Mutual Fund vs. the ETF

    The performance differences have narrowed between the two funds recently, and Morningstar's Tim Strauts and Eric Jacobson say PIMCO investors should choose the least expensive option.

  3. Four Questions for Fidelity

    Fidelity's Ron O'Hanley answers our questions on the balance between consistency and outperformance, the role of its multi-manager funds, enhancements to its fund boards, and the firm's vision for ETFs.

  4. The Friday Five

    Five stats from the market and the stories behind them. This week: Treasury yields on the rise, a nine-month low in China, and more.

Telecom at a Crossroads: What ETF Investors Need to Know

Given so much ongoing M&A activity, the telecom sector has been capturing a considerable amount of headlines lately. Below, a look at what is going on in the industry, and ways ETF investors can invest in telecom.

Robert Goldsborough, 06/14/2013

The U.S. telecommunications sector currently sits at something of a crossroads.

While the sector remains dominated by heavyweights AT&T T and Verizon Communications VZ, a raft of merger-and-acquisition activity is going on among the next-largest carriers in a process whose outcome is far from clear. Although most carriers have done a solid job managing and navigating the ongoing transition from voice service to data service, all players are grappling with how industry pricing will shake out, particularly in light of the ongoing consolidation activity. Positively, the telecom sector certainly is not the roll-up sector that it once was, and--with several notable exceptions--its participants aren't facing significant financial leverage. In fact, several players now pay significant dividends, and many have the flexibility to make the kinds of capital investments necessary to strengthen their networks.

For investors interested in broad exposure to the telecom sector as a whole, an exchange-traded fund can make a lot of sense. Large ETFs offer investors exposure not just to the twin titans in AT&T and Verizon but also to many of the smaller players that focus on specific regions or service offerings. And in an ETF, an investor can gain the best of both worlds--upside from the sector as the wireless side of the industry continues to grow and data service grows unabated, along with a fairly dependable income stream in the 2.5% to 3% range.

The Lay of the Land: Behemoths AT&T and Verizon, and the Next Level Below
AT&T and Verizon long have dominated the U.S. telecom industry by virtue of their size and their industry-leading margins. Both AT&T and Verizon's part-owned subsidiary, Verizon Wireless, have strong competitive positions in the wireless business. Both firms also are struggling with a fixed-line business that is in transition, as many customers are ditching their land lines but still are using their fixed lines for Internet access. AT&T has rebounded from a couple of setbacks, including its failed attempt to acquire T-Mobile TMUS. It also has been relatively unscathed from the loss of its iPhone exclusivity, as customer defections have remained low. Verizon has done a solid job keeping Verizon Wireless' competitive position intact but also is seeing its fixed-line business under pressure from cable companies and an eroding customer base. Both firms have very loyal postpaid customer bases. And more broadly, both firms are navigating a very tricky transition. For both firms, voice provides the majority of wireless revenue, but industry competition and declining usage are pressuring that revenue stream. Data revenue continues to grow, but the firms are trying to figure out how best to find their "sweet spot" with tiered data-pricing plans. However, that tiered model is being challenged directly by several smaller competitors, such as Sprint Nextel S  and T-Mobile TMUS.

Below AT&T and Verizon are firms such as Sprint Nextel, T-Mobile, and CenturyLink CTL. In general, the firms' margins are lower, their balance sheets are more leveraged, and they have struggled to retain customers and improve profitability. As a result, those players generally tend to price slightly below AT&T and Verizon to offer what we would say is comparable service.

Everybody Wants More Spectrum
One of the biggest issues facing the U.S. telecom industry is its desire for more wireless spectrum to meet customer needs. Currently being debated in the halls of Congress is what the federal government's stance should be toward limiting AT&T and Verizon's access to spectrum in upcoming wireless spectrum auctions (likely in 2014 or 2015) in favor of smaller carriers, versus allowing the free market to determine the winners in future Federal Communications Commission spectrum auctions. The two behemoths actually have occasionally practiced a form of "coopetition" in recent years when it comes to spectrum. Most notably, AT&T spent nearly $2 billion in early 2013 to buy unused wireless airwaves from Verizon Wireless. More broadly, ever since the failure of its bid to acquire T-Mobile, AT&T has been making smaller spectrum deals to boost its high-speed wireless network and catch up with Verizon Wireless, which is the dominant leader in next-generation spectrum.

Regardless of the timing of and any restrictions on future FCC auctions, the potential to acquire more wireless spectrum can offer upside to carriers as they seek to broaden their networks. And acquiring spectrum also is an obvious future use for carriers' free cash flows. While some investors might be concerned that increased spectrum investments could place pressure on telecom-services firms' abilities to pay steady dividends, we don't see upcoming spectrum buys as being so large or impactful that they would limit dividend payments. What's more, details regarding future spectrum auctions still remain very unclear. The timing is uncertain, and it's still not known just how much spectrum the current spectrum holders, television stations, will be willing to give up.

Ongoing M&A: What Does It Mean for Everyone?
Right now, several key merger-and-acquisition moves that have occurred recently or that are pending have grabbed headlines. The situation remains fluid as of this writing. T-Mobile recently closed on its acquisition of MetroPCS. Meanwhile, satellite TV subscription titan DISH Network DISH and Japanese mobile operator SoftBank have been battling to acquire Sprint Nextel. This has been occurring at the same time that Dish and Sprint have dueling bids to acquire Clearwire CLWR. (Sprint currently is the majority investor in Clearwire and is hoping to bring the company under full control.) It's still not clear to us how that situation will resolve itself. On top of all of this, Verizon long has wanted to buy the 45% of Verizon Wireless that currently is owned by Vodafone VOD.

Robert Goldsborough is an ETF Analyst at Morningstar.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.