• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>How Fund Companies Stack Up in Our Analyst Ratings

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. 5 Fund Picks for Dividend Investors

    Morningstar's Russ Kinnel shares his favorite funds for dividend growth and dividend yield.

  2. 3 of the Best Small -Value Funds Today

    American Beacon Small Cap Value and Diamond Hill Small Cap are two strong active options that are still accepting new investors, while Vanguard Small Cap Value is a great passive choice, says Morningstar's Russ Kinnel.

  3. Our Favorite Allocation Funds

    Morningstar's Russ Kinnel explores our favorite conservative fund options in our new allocation categories.

  4. Behind Vanguard's Surprising China Decision

    Is it out of character for the normally conservative fund firm to add volatile China A-shares to its Emerging Markets Index Fund?

How Fund Companies Stack Up in Our Analyst Ratings

Stepping back to see the forest for the trees.

Russel Kinnel, 05/22/2017

This article was originally published in the April 2017 issue of Morningstar FundInvestor and represents Morningstar Analyst Ratings as of that date. Download a complimentary copy of FundInvestor here.

Heading our U.S. Morningstar Analyst Ratings committees gives me a useful vantage point for spotting trends at fund companies. Are we getting more bullish or bearish about a fund company? Is there a certain team at a firm that is a growing cause for concern? If we spot something like that, we'll dig in to be sure we understand the big picture and have funds rated accordingly.

Let's see how that big picture looks. I've built a table that shows the largest fund companies' Morningstar Analyst Ratings breakdown, ratings changes, asset size, and flow data. The changes shown are during the past 12 months. When looking at the changes, keep in mind that we rate more funds from the largest firms, so, as a percentage of rated funds, a few downgrades or upgrades are not necessarily a big percentage of a firm's money under management. This look is limited to open-end funds, though we recently started rating exchange-traded funds, and target-date funds are counted only once.

Who Comes Out on Top?
Before I get to the trends, let's examine the big picture to see who is most impressive. I pulled the percentage of Morningstar Medalists among rated funds and then highlighted the percentage of Gold-rated funds to get an idea of which firms stand out. If I were picking a fund company, I'd prob­ably start with those figures. The graph shows the distribution of ratings for the largest fund companies. The big table shows ratings, upgrades, downgrades, the percentage of rated fund medalists, the percentage of rated funds that are Gold, fund flow trends, and market share.


Source: Morningstar.

Of all the data, the figure of 94% is the most striking. That is, 94% of the Vanguard funds we rate are medalists. Considering that we rate 80 Vanguard funds, it's truly remarkable. That nicely sums up why Vanguard is taking in an unheard of amount of new money from fund investors. That's a particularly difficult feat to pull off for a firm that is the largest fund company in the world, but indexing has scale that active management does not. Vanguard also has an impressive 38% of rated funds at Gold.

Two smaller firms boast 100% of rated funds as medalists. DFA and Dodge & Cox have been very consistent at delivering value to investors, though with fewer funds and less money than Vanguard. Even more impressive, though, is that Dodge & Cox has a perfect five Gold medalists out of five rated funds. Its focus and dedication to long-term thinking have built some great funds.

Looking at the percentage of medalist funds, a number of other big firms have fared quite well. Ten of the largest 11 firms have a majority of funds rated as medalists. Only Franklin Templeton fell below the line. The figure tails off after that, but TIAA-CREF is kind of an odd duck, with 91% of rated funds as medalists but lacking any Silver- or Gold-rated funds. While TIAA-CREF has fairly low costs and consistent performance, it doesn't really foster the elite investing skills that would take a fund to a Silver or Gold rating.

Russel Kinnel is Morningstar's director of mutual fund research. He is also the editor of Morningstar FundInvestor, a monthly newsletter dedicated to helping investors pick great mutual funds, build winning portfolios, and monitor their funds for greater gains. (Click here for a free issue). Mr. Kinnel would like to hear from readers, but no financial-planning questions, please. Follow Russel on Twitter: @russkinnel.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.