• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>Fund Firms Cashing in Despite Move to Lower-Cost Funds

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. 3 Inflation-Fighting Assets for Your Toolkit

    TIPS, real estate, and commodities are great inflation-hedging, liquid investments, says Morningstar's David Blanchett, who details the importance of exposure to these assets.

  2. Don't Fall Victim to the Next Dividend Cut

    With more firms decreasing (or eliminating) their payouts, DividendInvestor editor Josh Peters highlights what investors should look for to ensure stable, long -term dividend income.

  3. Time for the 3% Withdrawal Rule?

    Low bond yields have called into question the safety of the 4% withdrawal strategy, while other avenues for extra retirement income have their own pros and cons, says Morningstar's David Blanchett.

  4. Bargains Lacking for Dividend Funds

    Recent Morningstar research shows that while some buys exist across the equity fund universe, many areas, such as dividend-paying stocks , are close to fully valued.

Fund Firms Cashing in Despite Move to Lower-Cost Funds

Industry fee revenue at record high, even though investors pay less for funds overall.

Michael Rawson, CFA, 04/28/2015

Asset management is often described as a scalable business. After all, the costs of managing a fund don't significantly increase when a fund goes from $1 billion to $2 billion in assets. In fact, funds spread their costs over more assets as funds grow, often leading to declines in expense ratios as assets increase.

Indeed, during the past decade, the asset-weighted expense ratio across all funds (including mutual funds and exchange-traded products, or ETPs, but excluding money market funds and funds of funds) has fallen to 0.64% from 0.87%, which is a decline of 27%. 

Yet, in that same span, industry assets under management have increased 143%. We can estimate industry fee revenue by multiplying the asset-weighted expense ratio by total assets under management. By this measure, industry fee revenue is at an all-time high, reaching $88 billion, up from $50 billion 10 years ago. That is an increase of 78%. Thus, a much larger share of the benefits of the increase in assets under management have stayed with the fund industry rather than being returned to fund shareholders.

(Some) Fees Are Falling (Though Not by Much)
The asset-weighted expense ratio for all funds fell to 0.64% in 2014 from 0.76% in 2009, a decline of 15%. However, during this span, just 63% of the fund share classes and ETPs that existed in both 2009 and 2014 reduced their expense ratios and only about 24% of them saw their fees fall by more than 10%. Meanwhile, 21% of the share classes we examined ratcheted up their take. 

Nearly half of all funds have established management-fee breakpoints in their prospectuses, whereby expense ratios are automatically reduced at prespecified asset thresholds. As the current bull market has grown long in the horns, many funds have crossed these thresholds because of some combination of asset-price appreciation and net new flows. While some fees are falling, that's been driven primarily by investorsmoving their assets to low-cost funds--not by steep cuts in fund expenses.

Fees by Type
While the annual report net expense ratio includes all explicit fees incurred by a fund, these fees can be disaggregated and itemized according to their various sources, such as the advisor (management) fees, administration fees, distribution fees, and so on. Not all firms break out these expenses nor are they listed in a transparent and consistent way to help investment decision-makers.

Michael Rawson, CFA is an ETF Analyst with Morningstar.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Upcoming Events

©2014 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.