• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>A Look Back at 4 Unpopular Picks

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. Three Things to Watch Following Vanguard's Index Swap

    Investors should keep tabs on a few key indicators as Vanguard switches the benchmarks for 22 of its index funds.

  2. Sauter: Cost Certainty Key With New Benchmarks

    Vanguard's CIO says the fund shop is looking forward to the substantial long-term cost savings and price stability once it transitions to the FTSE and CRSP indexes, beginning next year.

  3. Answering ETF Concerns

    Vanguard principal and ETF strategist Joel Dickson responds to worries that increased passive investing has led to more market volatility and that ETFs cause investors to gamble with their portfolios.

  4. Bogle: Most Difficult Investment Conditions I've Ever Seen

    The Vanguard founder says the kind of returns we've gotten in the past are not going to happen--period.

A Look Back at 4 Unpopular Picks

Patience is rewarded for sticking with these former laggards.

Russel Kinnel, 10/30/2012

The most commonly asked questions about our Analyst Ratings inevitably involve instances when ratings appear to be out of sync with trailing three-year returns. We tend to take a longer-term view, and experience tells us that three-year performance can flip very quickly. But that doesn't mean we're oblivious to returns. Rather, we're more focused on returns in the time period since the manager took over and on how the fund performed in various market environments.

To illustrate our approach, I dusted off the July 2007 issue of FundInvestor and pulled four of the Analyst Picks with the worst relative performance in trailing three-year returns and a manager tenure of at least three years. I then looked at the ensuing five-year returns and our current rating. Of the four, all outperformed during the ensuing five years. Two are rated Gold, one Silver, and one Neutral.

Aston Montag & Caldwell Growth MCGFX
Category three-year rank then: 74
Category five-year rank now: 25 
Current Analyst Rating: Gold

This fund has been consistent in approach and management. Ron Canakaris and team built a strong record, but their strategy isn't one that will work over every three-year period. They look for big companies with strong brands trading at a moderate price. When mega-caps and quality go out of favor, this fund lags. However, as those names have some defensive qualities, the fund generally performs relatively well in down markets, so it's not all that hard to hold. In fact, the fund lost less than its peers in 2008 and 2011; that's why it now boasts strong five-year figures.

American Funds Washington Mutual AWSHX
Category three-year rank then: 71
Category five-year rank now: 22
Current Analyst Rating: Gold

Low costs, management and analyst depth, and consistency make this an easy one for us to stick with even though it, too, goes in and out of favor. Outside of a sluggish 2009, this fund has posted strong relative performance since 2007. We were recommending it when it was out of favor, too, in 1999. As you can see from these two funds, our ratings reflect our view of a fund's long-term prospects, but we're not trying to make short-term calls about when their style will go out of favor.

Vanguard U.S. Value VUVLX
Category three-year rank then: 81 
Category five-year rank now: 42
Current Analyst Rating: Neutral

This fund has undergone the most changes in our ratings and in management and strategy. That's no accident, as our ratings are fundamentally driven. We dropped the fund from our picks list in August 2007 because Vanguard added AXA Rosenberg to run a portion of the fund alongside Grantham, Mayo, Von Oterloo. Our concern wasn't the weak three-year return, but that GMO's impact was being diluted. Our view further dimmed when Vanguard replaced GMO with its own Quantitative Equity Group and boosted the expense ratio, though it was still low. Then in 2010, Vanguard fired AXA Rosenberg because it had messed up its quant models and failed to notify Vanguard in a timely fashion. Today, QEG is the sole manager and Vanguard has lowered fees. QEG is decent, but the fund has to prove itself.

Russel Kinnel is Morningstar's director of mutual fund research. He is also the editor of Morningstar FundInvestor, a monthly newsletter dedicated to helping investors pick great mutual funds, build winning portfolios, and monitor their funds for greater gains. (Click here for a free issue). Mr. Kinnel would like to hear from readers, but no financial-planning questions, please. Follow Russel on Twitter: @russkinnel.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.