• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles

We're Too Smart

Knowing a lot can be a powerful tool, but like all tools, how you choose to use it can determine your success or failure.

Carl Richards, 04/03/2012

This article originally appeared in the April/May 2012 issue of MorningstarAdvisor magazine. To subscribe, please call 1-800-384-4000.

Part of what makes us so good at helping people with money is that we know a lot. It’s this knowledge that allows us to help people untangle their finances and set goals for the future. But I think this knowledge can just as easily trip us up.

In Made to Stick, the authors, Chip and Dan Heath, refer to it as the curse of knowledge. How does the curse work? Let’s use a first client meeting as an example.

Into your office walk Bill and Mary Smith. Both have college degrees, good jobs, and a mortgage, but the extent of their financial knowledge is setting up a contribution to their company’s 401(k). These are smart people (they came to you, right?) who know that they need to make financial plans, but they aren’t sure where to start. They’ve come to you for help. How do you begin?

Do you start by rattling off a list of different indexes, rate of returns, or annual contribution limits? If so, you’re triggering the curse of knowledge. The Smiths are unlikely to be your first clients or your last, and you’re so comfortable with the material that it’s easy to forget that not everyone else is, too. The point, as we learn in Made to Stick, isn’t to “dumb things down,” but to find a “universal language.”

Using industry jargon and assuming that the client knows exactly what we’re talking about is a trap we all need to avoid. We know too much, and if we aren’t careful, it shows. As advisors, we need to think back to that first day in class and remember how little we knew and how foreign the words and acronyms sounded. We need to realize that the first meeting with an advisor may very well be the equivalent of our client’s first day in class.

Instead of abstract terms, use concrete examples. Don’t start off by talking about a rate of return. Do start by asking about the monthly budget. Talk in terms that are relevant as opposed to some far off future, and you’ll be surprised at how clients respond. You’re talking in their terms, but you’re still getting information that helps you help them.

We need to embrace the reality that we may end up being a teacher as much as an advisor. Some people will come to you with more knowledge, some with less, but all will respect you and our profession more if they feel like we’ve treated them with respect. Knowing a lot can be a powerful tool, but like all tools, how you choose to use it can determine your success or failure.

The author is a freelance contributor to MorningstarAdvisor.com. The views expressed in this article may or may not reflect the views of Morningstar.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.