Four offerings deemed to be right for right now.
Stock: 3M MMM
Fair Value Estimate: $100
Morningstar Rating: 5 Stars
Uncertainty: Low
Economic Moat: Wide
Credit Rating: AA
3M has invented some of the world’s greatest
products. We think that the firm’s innovative
culture, bottom-line focus, and low-cost
manufacturing have carved a wide moat around
its business that will enable the company to
reap outsized rewards over the long run.
Although 3M sells thousands of products to
disparate end markets, the firm cites only a few
dozen technological pillars that support its wide
array of offerings. Recent economic headwinds
challenged this profitability because of the
firm’s inherent operating leverage, but we think
3M handled the 2008–09 recession admirably,
reducing working capital to increase free cash
flow while remaining economically profitable.
Adam Fleck
Mutual Fund: Litman Gregory Masters Value MSVFX
Category: Large Blend
Morningstar Rating: 3 Stars
Total Assets: $86.8 million
Expenses: 1.37%
Turnover: 8.8%
This fund’s portfolio comprises the nine to 15
best ideas of four proven subadvisors. That
should have been a winning formula, particularly
with Bill Nygren of Oakmark Select OAKLX,
Mason Hawkins of Longleaf Partners LLPFX,
and a team from Mutual Series on board since
the fund’s 2000 inception. However, the
struggles of the fourth manager, Bill Miller of
Legg Mason, in 2007 and 2008 put a big dent
in the fund’s record. Miller was canned in 2008
in favor of Clyde McGregor of Oakmark
Equity & Income OAKBX. At the time, the fund
had lagged the Russell 3000 Value Index since
inception. Since then, it’s trounced the index
as well as its typical large-value peer. The fund
is a fine long-term holding.
Greg Carlson
Separate Account: Leuthold Weeden Core Investments
Category: Moderate Allocation
Total Number of Holdings: 61
P/B Ratio: 1.98
U.S. Stocks: 65.64%
Net Assets: $1.771 billion
Assets in Top 10 Holdings: 39.55%
Economic growth is muted in the biggest
markets, and smaller corners of the market
could end up delivering better returns, so a
wide-ranging asset-allocation strategy
may be just the ticket. Leuthold Weeden runs
one of the best around. It has generated fine
long-term returns while owning U.S. equities
and bonds, emerging-markets stocks, foreign
sovereign debt, gold bullion, and cash. The fund
will also dramatically alter its stock/bond
mix depending on the macroeconomic forecasts
of the management team and its quant models.
Firm founder Steve Leuthold recently stepped
down from his CIO and portfolio-manager roles,
but he’ll still be quite involved in the investment
process.
Greg Carlson
Exchange-Traded Fund: WisdomTree Asia Local Debt ALD
Category: Emerging-Markets Bond
Expense Ratio: 0.55%
AUM: $417 million
SEC yield: 2.43%
Effective duration: 2.75 years
Average credit quality: BBB
WisdomTree Asia Local Debt invests primarily
in local currency government bonds of
12 Asian countries, excluding Japan but
including Australia. The fund is suitable as a
satellite holding for investors looking
for exposure to potentially appreciating Asian
currencies. One risk to note is that while
most Asian currencies have strong fundamentals,
foreign fund flows, especially during
periods of high market volatility, can drive
fluctuating exchange rates.
This ETF does not follow a strict benchmark and
can be considered active because managers
have some discretion to pick countries and
securities for inclusion. The country-selection
process is based on the depth and liquidity
of the markets and also incorporates political
and economic factors.
Patricia Oey
Hindsight: October/November 2010
The picks from one year ago include no big
winners or losers, as befits a market
environment characterized by very modest
returns. Stock pick Home Depot HD gained 7%
for the period compared with 1% for the
S&P 500; moves to focus on its core retail
business have begun to bear fruit. Meanwhile,
ETF pick Vanguard Information Technology VGT
finished slightly ahead of the index with
a 3% gain as successes like Apple AAPL have
out-weighed disappointments like Hewlett-
Packard HPQ. Separate account pick Westwood
Capital Management Balanced Portfolio
has lagged the Morningstar Moderate Target
Risk Index by a narrow margin because
of its focus on the largest companies. Finally,
mutual fund pick Templeton Global
Total Return TGTRX trailed its benchmark,
the Barclays Capital Multiverse Index,
by 5 percentage points as its currency bets fell
flat when the markets tanked in August and
September.
Greg Carlson
Pick: Home Depot HD
Type: Stock
Cumulative Return to Date (%): 6.82
Back Then, We Said: “Upgrades will strengthen its competitive position”
Now, We Say: “Should continue to improve its supply chain”
Pick: Templeton Global Total Return A TGTRX
Type: Mutual Fund
Cumulative Return to Date (%): -1.17
Back Then, We Said: “Proven manager with more levers to pull”
Now, We Say: “Should succeed, but it’s only for patient investors”
Pick: Vanguard Information Technology ETF VGT
Type: ETF
Cumulative Return to Date (%): 2.67
Back Then, We Said: “Offers broad exposure to the undervalued tech sector”
Now, We Say: “Monitor valuation in this intensely competitive sector”
Pick: Westwood Capital Management
Type: Separate Account
Cumulative Return to Date (%): –0.74
Back Then, We Said: “Quality bias has served it well over time”
Now, We Say: “Well-equipped to handle any bumps ahead”
Cumulative Return to Date (%)
S&P 500 TR: 1.14
BarCap Multiverse TR USD: 3.85
Morningstar Moderate Target Risk: 1.03