And there are a few compelling options in this category.
World-allocation funds have the broadest purviews in the mutual fund universe. Only they, world-stock offerings, and world-bond funds have the leeway to scour the entire globe for investment opportunities without concern about geographic borders. World-allocation funds can--and do--make full use of the asset-class spectrum, while world-stock offerings focus on equities and world-bond funds concentrate on fixed-income securities.
This breadth has been quite helpful in 2008's terrible conditions. World-allocation funds devote around 40% of their assets to a mix of cash, short-term credits, and higher-quality intermediate-term U.S. and foreign bonds. Those asset classes have eked out tiny gains or posted limited losses this year, while equities have plunged around the globe. Therefore, though they're down a painful 21%, world-allocation funds have lost 9 percentage points less than world-stock offerings as well as 3 to 7 percentage points less than domestic large-cap funds and 10 to 14 percentage points less than foreign large-cap offerings for the year to date through Oct. 3.
Significant Long-Term Success
This year's outperformance is certainly no fluke. World-allocation funds have comfortably outpaced world-stock offerings over the trailing three-, five-, 10-, and 15-year periods, and their returns over those periods look quite good relative to those of domestic large-cap funds and pretty good relative to those of foreign large-cap offerings. And not surprisingly, given the moderating effects of their fixed-income stakes, these funds have suffered significantly less volatility than all of those types of offerings. Further, while world-allocation funds have lost more than moderate-allocation offerings (which mainly stick to the U.S.) this year, largely because foreign stocks have suffered more than domestic ones, these funds have better long-term risk reward profiles than those offerings, as their broader geographic range has generally been helpful.
Of course, these funds won't always post superior returns. They've benefited from the facts that bonds have performed exceptionally well relative to equities over the past decade and that foreign securities have fared better than their domestic counterparts (partly due to weakness in the U.S. dollar). They will be at big disadvantage relative to world-stock, domestic large-cap, and foreign large-cap offerings whenever stocks mount strong rallies, and they will be at big disadvantage relative to moderate-allocation offerings whenever U.S. securities dominate their overseas competition. Still, there is real merit to allowing managers to invest wherever they can find attractive opportunities; these funds have proven they can deliver attractive returns with modest volatility over the very long run; and they tend to be less expensive than world-stock offerings and comparably priced with moderate-allocation funds. Thus, world-allocation funds are quite worthy of attention from risk-conscious investors who are seeking core offerings to build around as well as those who are in search of stand-alone holdings.
Look Before You Leap
Such investors do need to choose carefully, though. Roughly half of the 54 world-allocation funds opened in 2006, 2007, or earlier this year and thus are unproven. And the untested funds aren't the only ones that should be approached warily or avoided outright. Some of the more-established offerings have serious flaws and should be shunned. Above-average expenses, an uninspiring record, and some errant decision making in recent years make Evergreen Asset Allocation
Personnel issues have also lessened the previously exceptional appeal of First Eagle Global
We are, however, becoming increasingly confident about Thornburg Investment Income Builder
Finally, there are two world-allocation funds that boast a broad array of strengths and that we have long believed in: American Funds Capital Income Builder
William Samuel Rocco is a fund analyst with Morningstar.
Get mutual fund and stock information from our analyst team delivered to your e-mail inbox every Tuesday. Sign up for our free Investment Insights e-newsletter.