These three funds offer good long-term value in an attractive total package.
This article originally appeared in the December issue of Morningstar FundInvestor.
It's hardly a news flash that last September's financial industry upheaval took the phrase "crisis of confidence" to a whole new level in the bond market. As investors worldwide sold riskier assets in a mass stampede to safety in the months that followed, Treasuries reigned supreme while bonds without government backing got clobbered. That explains how Vanguard Long-Term U.S. Treasury
Although Treasury rates have begun to rise off their lows in recent weeks, few could argue that their still-anemic yields--whether just several tenths of a percent on the three-month Treasury bill or 2.40% on the 10-year note--have much to offer long-term investors, particularly as government policies aimed at getting the economy back on track could stoke inflation. And with nowhere for Treasury yields to go but up, Treasury-heavy funds that won big in 2008 could easily become tomorrow's losers (as yields rise, prices on outstanding bonds fall).
That isn't the case for the corporate sector, though. In October and November, some investment-grade corporate bonds have offered yields as high as 8% or 9%, representing an additional 5 to 6 percentage points over Treasuries. The average yield on junk bonds recently climbed higher than 20%, setting a new record. We've heard analysts and investors estimate that these prices reflect corporate defaults spiking to worse levels than those seen during the Great Depression, a view many think is overly pessimistic. Although corporate bonds have recovered some ground in recent weeks--as of Jan. 8, the yield on the Barclays Capital U.S. Corporate Investment Grade Index had dropped to 7.3%, down from 9.1% at the end of October, and the Barclays Capital High Yield Index currently yields 18%--many managers argue that there's still plenty of value to be had in the corporate sector.
Still, plump double-digit yields on junk bonds aren't exactly a no-brainer for investors. With the economy continuing to deteriorate, there's almost certainly more pain to come in the form of defaults. Another question mark is the amount that a bond investor can expect to recover in the event that a company actually does go bust. Some investors are concerned that the torrent of senior bank loans issued in recent years--which have a higher priority claim on a company's assets--could take a bite out of how much investors have historically expected to recover from a default (close to 40 cents on the dollar for senior unsecured debt, according to Moody's). The frozen credit markets could also prove especially challenging for high-yield issuers, which rely heavily on debt financing to keep their businesses going. If the market doesn't thaw soon, companies that need to refinance their debt in coming months could find the crippling cost of issuing new debt insurmountable. As an added wrinkle, mutual fund investors have to contend with the risk that their fellow shareholders could lose their nerve and head for the exits, causing fund managers to sell bonds at distressed levels.
Although mistakes may be nearly impossible for high-yield bond-fund managers to avoid in the year ahead, those managers who do a good job of dodging the most troubled firms should come out ahead. Our favorites in the category--like Fidelity High Income
For investors who are nervous about the rocky road ahead for high-yield, the good news is that many managers actually like the prospects for investment-grade corporate bonds even more. The following three funds are top choices for investors interested in adding some corporates into their own portfolio mix.
Dodge & Cox Income
T. Rowe Price Corporate Income
Loomis Sayles Bond