To make the cut at FMI Large Cap, a stock must go through an intensive examination.
We value your comments. Make your opinions known at the end of every MorningstarAdvisor.com article.
Shareholders of Fiduciary Management Inc.'s funds could have been forgiven if they thought their funds had gone on a hiring spree in early 2009. FMI funds run by a couple of managers all of a sudden listed a half dozen or so more portfolio managers. But these weren't new hires. Rather, executives at FMI wanted to highlight the fact that the stock selection and research is done by a team of analysts. They also wanted to recognize the analysts' contributions to the entire research process. Analysts at FMI are generalists--they are not tied to specific sectors or industries--and they are collectively involved in every buy and sell decision made in the portfolio.
This total-team approach is different than the sector-aligned structures of most firms, and it is a key driver of FMI's success. Because they study many different industries, FMI's analysts are able to contribute to the debate of whether a stock should be included in the firm's compact portfolios. FMI doesn't compensate analysts based on the performance of their picks. Rather, it's the quality of their ideas and insights that count.
Milwaukee: Home of the Boutique
Milwaukee might not be the financial hub that is Chicago, which is just 90 miles to the south, but it is home to a handful of strong-performing boutique asset managers. One of the best is FMI, which Don Wilson and Ted Kellner founded in 1980. (They had worked together at in-town rival Nicholas Co.) The next year, in 1981, the firm launched its flagship fund, FMI Common Stock
FMI Large Cap has pushed past its category peers with just a handful of well-researched picks. The fund holds 27 stocks, while its average peer has nearly 150 holdings. The team buys companies with strong franchises, high recurring revenues, defensible market positions, and stock prices below the FMI's fair value estimates. FMI backs up this philosophy with conviction by building a truly actively managed, long-term-oriented portfolio. Few, if any, of the attributes the team requires of a stock change dramatically in the short term.
Because Large Cap is a compact portfolio, the team manages stock-specific risk, so a hiccup at one or two picks doesn't sink returns. The analysts plow through nearly all available information about a company, looking for anything that may undermine the thesis for owning it. Their recommendations are then presented to the broader committee. Team members attempt to pick apart the thesis before collectively deciding whether the stock is worthy of the portfolio.
This research and presentation takes time. Large Cap's 26% average turnover for the past three years indicates a stock holding period of nearly four years. The typical large-blend fund has a 65% average turnover for the same time period. In 2008, the fund only added net two positions to the portfolio. (Management added six stocks and eliminated four.) Most of the fund's inflows last year went into building positions in its current holdings.
Valuation Is Key
The fund is a stock-picker's domain, but the team has a clear eye on the world around it. When changes are made to the portfolio, the key driver is valuation. The team will gladly sit on the sidelines and wait for an attractive company to come down to a reasonable valuation. At the same time, the managers will take money off the table rather than stretch for that last dollar of gains at the expense of additional volatility. The team, for example, trimmed its position in Wal-Mart
Growth matters to the team, but so does how a company achieves it. The team sold office-goods supplier Staples
Pat English, FMI's head of equity research, says that the firm has become more defensive based on its outlook of the economy. The team has been trimming Large Cap's cyclical exposure in names such as Rockwell
English says that he doesn't see enough demand in the economy to support the robust growth assumptions of many large-cap stocks. The team rotated the fund's assets toward defensive names that can weather uncertainty. In addition to adding to Time Warner, the team recently increased the fund's exposure to stable stocks such as Wal-Mart and consumer foods icon Nestle
As evident by their patient, deliberate actions, the managers don't chase fads. The fund's 12% weight in financials is a similar exposure to the S&P 500 Index's 14% weighting, but the holdings couldn't be more different. J.P. Morgan Chase and Co.
A Stable Outlook
In 1986, Wilson and Kellner, the firm's cofounders, hired English as a research analyst; English was a Stanford graduate with just one year of experience at Dodge & Cox. The relationship has worked exceptionally well. English's progression to head of research allowed Wilson and Kellner to step back from research many years ago. They leave it to English and a handful of analysts to execute the firm's team-based approach.
The team is tight-knit, and continuity is central to the firm's appeal. Wilson plans to retire at the end of 2009, but a transition plan has been in place for a decade. His and Kellner's stakes in the shop will be purchased by the firm's investment personnel over the next 10 years, erasing any doubt about future ownership. John Brandser, a partner, has been taking on Wilson's duties and will eventually assume the title of chief compliance officer.
FMI's temperament and execution through both market turmoil and rally finally garnered investors' attention in 2008. Despite the Large Cap fund's 26% decline, longtime investors were joined by newcomers; net assets increased almost threefold to $1.5 billion from $639 million in 2008. More inflows and strong performance pushed assets to $2 billion in September. The firm reopened Common Stock in February, and assets have poured in. FMI announced that it will again close the fund to new investors at the end of December. English says that capacity isn't currently a concern at the Large Cap fund, but should asset growth remain strong, the firm will close the fund rather than have new money dilute its high-conviction portfolio.
The firm now manages more than $6 billion in assets. To help meet the demands of asset growth, the firm increased its client-service team, and it recently sold its mutual fund administration and accounting servicing operations to U.S. Bancorp's Fund Services unit. The divestiture will allow team members to focus on the firm's core-investment management.
FMI Large Cap has outperformed in virtually every market environment since its inception. For investors comfortable with its stock-specific risk and who understand that the fund won't change its stripes if the market moves away from its portfolio, this fund is an easy choice.
Andrew Gogerty is a senior fund analyst with Morningstar.
We value your feedback! Add your questions, comments, or criticism by clicking the link below.