• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>Small Caps vs. Large: Managers Make Their Pitch

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. Behind Vanguard's Surprising China Decision

    Is it out of character for the normally conservative fund firm to add volatile China A-shares to its Emerging Markets Index Fund ?

  2. Why Vanguard Was Hard to Beat in 2014

    It was tough for active managers to outpace Vanguard's low-cost index funds in 2014, and many of its active funds also outperformed.

  3. Vanguard's Leaders and Laggards

    Morningstar's Dan Culloton sizes up the fund firm's top and bottom performers year-to-date, discusses CIO Gus Sauter's impending retirement, and more.

  4. How to Choose Between 2 Vanguard Dividend Funds

    Gold-rated Vanguard Dividend Growth and Silver-rated Vanguard Equity-Income are solid funds that ply distinct dividend strategies.

Small Caps vs. Large: Managers Make Their Pitch

Why big may be beautiful.

Ryan Leggio, 11/18/2010

Get mutual fund and stock information from our analyst team delivered to your e-mail inbox every Tuesday. Sign up for our free Investment Insights e-newsletter.

U.S. large-cap stocks have had a tough decade. Vanguard 500 Index VFINX is flat over the past 10 years through Oct. 22. Meanwhile, its smaller-cap sibling, Vanguard Small Cap Index NAESX, is up 6% per year over the same period.

Why have large caps trailed small caps? Valuation explains much of the discrepancy. In the 1990s, large-cap stocks trounced small caps with their 18% annualized gain versus small caps' still-healthy 14%. A decade of outsized returns pushed large-cap stocks' valuation multiples to all-time highs by 2000, just prior to the two-plus-year bear market that began that March. Ten years ago, the large-cap indexes traded at a lofty price/earnings ratio of 25. A smaller gain during the 1990s left small-cap indexes at a 14 P/E multiple.

Fast-forward 10 years. A decade of no gains for large caps has improved their relative valuation. As of Sept. 30, the trailing P/E ratio of the Vanguard 500 was 16 compared with 25 for the Vanguard Small Cap Index.

Now that the valuation tables have turned, many managers think large caps will deliver better returns than small-cap stocks in the decade ahead. Here is what we've been hearing from a few prominent managers on the subject.

Buy Big Dopey
In a recent interview with Morningstar, Ben Inker of GMO, the subadvisor to Wells Fargo Advantage Asset Allocation EAAFX, said, "As we see it, large caps look cheap relative to small all around the world. And big value looks cheap relative to small value. And big growth looks cheap relative to small growth. We have spent a lot of time overweight small caps. We loved them from the late 1990s to the early to middle part of this decade, but now they're expensive, and the big dopey blue chips are a lot cheaper."PAGEBREAK

Opposites Attract
FPA Crescent FPACX manager Steven Romick said, "In the late 1990s . our fund was heavily tilted toward smaller-cap, high-quality companies because they were cheap. These companies were at 20% discounts to large-cap stocks in 1997, which was historically wide. They went to a 40% discount in 1999-2000, a new all-time high, and they stayed there for two years. Now we're at the opposite point in the cycle, and large-cap stocks are cheap by comparison--much cheaper than they've ever been versus small caps."

Same as It Ever Was
Bill Miller of Legg Mason Capital Management Value LMVTX thinks U.S. large-capitalization stocks represent a "once in a lifetime opportunity" to buy the best-quality companies in the world at bargain prices. He recently observed that one of the fund's holdings, ExxonMobil XOM, has a dividend yield greater than the 10-year Treasury, trades at a multiple well below the market's, has returns on capital above the market's, and has grown its dividend more than 9% per year the past five years.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.