Runners-Up for Manager of the Year

Get mutual fund and stock information from our analyst team delivered to your e-mail inbox every Tuesday. Sign up for our free Investment Insights e-newsletter.

We want to recognize our runners-up for Morningstar Manager of the Year 2010. These are managers who did outstanding jobs for investors and finished second in our analysts' vote. The Manager of the Year award is really more of a Hall of Fame recognition. We want to recognize managers who have made a lot of money for investors over the long haul and done so in a way that shows they take their duties to shareholders seriously. Our Analyst Picks, meanwhile, are meant as recommendations of what to own for the next 10 years.

Many past runners-up have gone on to win Manager of the Year. For example, Vanguard Capital Opportunity VHCOX managers Howard Schow, Theo Kolokotrones, and Joel Fried were runners-up in 1999 with a 99% return but went on to win in 2003. That same year, American Funds EuroPacific Growth AEPGX was a runner-up, and it won in 2009. In 2004, Loomis Sayles Bond's LSBRX Dan Fuss and Kathleen Gaffney were runners-up, and they claimed the prize in 2009. In 2005, Jeffrey Gundlach at TCW Total Return Bond TGLMX was runner-up but brought home the prize in 2006.

This year we are naming runners-up for domestic-stock and fixed-income. We are not naming an international-stock runner-up because no clear second-place finisher emerged in our vote for Manager of the Year. Click here to see the nominees. PAGEBREAK

Runner-Up Domestic-Stock Manager of the Year: Rick Aster Jr.
In 1984, Rick Aster Jr. launched Meridian Growth MERDX. Since that time, the fund has gained a cumulative 2,203% compared with a 952% gain for its benchmark. Now that's adding value.

Aster's strategy was well suited to the value-driven aughts. He wants steady double-digit growth, but he maintains a strict valuation discipline. In addition, he buys for the long haul and that keeps him away from Icarus-type stocks that fly high only to get burned.

His steady approach has worked well for shareholders as evidenced by the fund's investor returns, which are an estimate of how the fund's typical investor has fared. Its 10-year investor return through the end of December 2010 is 8.25%--top 11% in mid-growth--and its 15-year investor return is 8.9%--top 12%. The fund lost less in bear markets and gained as much or more than its peers in rallies. That's not easy to pull off, but it's the best formula for keeping investors on board through tough times so that they are around for the good times.

Runner-Up Fixed-Income Manager of the Year: Metropolitan West Team
Amid all the controversy over Jeffrey Gundlach's firing from TCW, not many people noticed that the MetWest team that took over did an excellent job at TCW Total Return Bond TGLMX and Metropolitan West Total Return Bond MWTRX.