• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Investment Insights>Can of Worms Still Open on Sokol Incident

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. Berkshire’s Energy Bet Well-Placed

    Berkshire Hathaway Energy will continue to provide plenty of profitable investment opportunities for years to come, says Morningstar's Andy Bischof.

  2. Questions for Buffett

    Morningstar's Gregg Warren, one of three analysts who will be quizzing Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger in Omaha, describes how he narrows down his list of questions to just six.

  3. What Will Berkshire Look Like Over the Next 50 Years?

    Morningstar's Gregg Warren discusses potential successors to Warren Buffett and how Berkshire might change after his departure.

  4. Berkshire After Buffett: Who Will Be the Next CEO ?

    Berkshire will be 'just fine' with either of the top candidates as long as they stick to Buffett's approach to capital allocation and decentralization, says Morningstar's Gregg Warren.

Can of Worms Still Open on Sokol Incident

A Berkshire board report finding Sokol in violation of ethics will not quiet the clamor over succession planning and other concerns at the firm.

Greggory Warren, 04/29/2011

In a surprise move, the board of directors at Berkshire Hathaway BRK.A BRK.B released the findings of their own internal investigation into the trading activity of David Sokol, former chairman of MidAmerican Energy and former chairman and CEO of NetJets, in shares of Lubrizol LZ prior to that company being acquired by Berkshire in March of this year.

The board found that Sokol not only violated the company's trading policies (and its code of conduct) by purchasing shares of Lubrizol "while serving as a representative of Berkshire Hathaway in connection with a possible business combination," but that his "misleadingly incomplete disclosures to Berkshire Hathaway senior management concerning those purchases violated the duty of candor" that he owed to the firm.

While this is in line with our view of the trading activity, and could put to rest some of the criticism that has been laid at Warren Buffett's feet in the aftermath of his oddly structured press release at the end of last month (which announced Sokol's departure and walked through the former employee's stock trades), it will not put a lid on the can of worms that has been opened as a result of this incident.

Even if Buffett is able to deflect a handful of questions about the Sokol affair at the annual meeting later this week, he (and the board) will not be able to ignore the clamor that has arisen about succession planning at Berkshire, nor the concerns that have emerged about the limitations of the decentralized nature of the company's business model.


©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.