• / Free eNewsletters & Magazine
  • / My Account
Home>Research & Insights>Fund Times>SEC Signs Off on Clean Share Proposal

Related Content

  1. Videos
  2. Articles
  1. Don't Overcomplicate Your Portfolio

    Consider target-date funds, mutual funds , or ETFs to help keep things simple, says Christine Benz.

  2. Kinnel's Favorite Funds for Diversification

    With U.S. markets hitting new highs, Morningstar's Russ Kinnel thinks investors would be well-served to look at these diversifying investments.

  3. Factor Investing Calls for Discipline, Diversification

    Big swings in 2016 performance highlight the challenges, and opportunities, of investing in strategic-beta funds, says Morningstar's Ben Johnson.

  4. How Mutual Funds Are Cleaning Up Their Pricing Act

    With 'clean shares,' mutual funds are removing some distribution fees. But is it too little, too late?

SEC Signs Off on Clean Share Proposal

SEC guidance allows brokers to set commissions for selling shares cleansed of distribution charges and enables investors to better compare costs.

Alec Lucas, 01/11/2017

On Jan. 11, 2017, the SEC approved what Capital Group hopes is a way forward for both brokers and investors. The regulator said brokers can set their own commissions for selling clean shares, which include management fees and administrative charges but no distribution costs. That should give investors a better idea of what they’re paying to brokers and asset managers for their respective services. They’ll also be able to better compare the investment-related charges for clean shares of actively managed open-end mutual funds with exchange-traded funds.

Investors who seek financial advice should have more options. They’ll be able to weigh the relative costs of fee-based versus commission-based accounts. As John Rekenthaler recently pointed out, the T shares newly launched by many asset managers, which carry a 2.5% load and an ongoing 0.25% 12b-1 fee, have lower sales charges than a 1% asset-based advisory charge when held for at least four years, and they become cheaper the longer they are held. Capital Group thinks investors will be even better served by the complete separation of distribution and investment charges. With the SEC’s guidance, financial advisors who opt for a brokerage model can now set their own commissions and choose to compete on cost, service, or some combination of the two. Beginning in 2017’s first quarter, Capital Group will offer F-3 shares those advisors can use. Unlike T shares, F-3 shares are clean because they carry no distribution-related charges.

The addition of T and F-3 shares is another indication that the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule is reshaping the landscape of mutual fund distribution. Set to go into effect starting in April 2017, the rule places a higher investment-recommendation standard on tax-qualified retirement accounts. The rule is likely to lead to the application of fiduciarylike obligations to taxable accounts as well. It has been widely expected that the rule will accelerate the shift from commission-based to fee-based accounts. With the SEC’s recent guidance, that could change.



is an analyst of active strategies on the manager research team for Morningstar.

©2017 Morningstar Advisor. All right reserved.